By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - WiiU Vs. XB1: Do you still think WiiU will win, if so why?

 

WiiU V.s XB1

WiiU will win 421 49.36%
 
XB1 will win 432 50.64%
 
Total:853
Hiku said:
TheJimbo1234 said:
Hiku said:
TheJimbo1234 said:

It won't ever take 2nd place, even with discounts etc.

The reason being the huge movement of causal gamers to mobile along with a very, very limited game base. If you see all the recent sales, big multiplats sell consoles well, and they come out every few weeks. However 1st party games come out rarely and few people are now interested in Nintendo games so it will struggle to sell. Also as more people become accustom to 8th gen graphics and gaming mechanics, the WiiU will just start to look older and dated.

The casual gamers were never part of the equation. I'm well aware of that situation. I was refering to things like a substantial price drop, bigger memory than 32gb, and first and foremost getting many more third party developers on board (aka paying them money). But I just don't think they're going to invest that much money into this.

Casual gamers were certainly part of the equation - they made up a huge market base which has now left consoles and some consoles eg WiiU are seeing the effects of this. The points you made are valid, but even if they do all of them, why would someone buy the WiiU over the PS4 or xbone? If you can afford to pay $60 per game, then why would you go for the cheaper console as your wallet would be able to afford the more powerful and more pricey console?

Sorry, when I said never part of the equation, I meant in my post about Wii U and what Nintendo can do about it's situation. I guess I should have been more clear, but I though by mentioning that "I'm well aware of that situation" would make it clear what I meant.
I wasn't counting on them to help the Wii U's sales to begin with, so I tried to point out why it wasn't a counter argument to my post. I hope that makes it more clear. lol

As for your current question about chosing a weaker console over a more powerful one, I think there are factors that can outweigh that. Having a strong library, and many exclusives are very important. PS2 was the weakest of the three consoles that generation, but became the most successful home console ever.
Say hypothetically that Nintendo have infinite money, and they buy every exclusive that's currently on PS and XB, both 3rd party and 2st party, and sell their console for $1, then they would most likely win the console war.
And extreme example, but the question is where the line is drawn for what the minimum effort they need to invest in, in order for them to pass XB1. And I think that line is much higher than they can, or are willing to afford.

True, a strong library does help, however the 7th gen saw publishers pretty much killed that option with multiplatform games (think back to ps2 - it had a strong lead time and had exclusives because there was no other console for a while). As you say, there is a line Nintendo could aim for, but they won't bother mainly due to CEO arrogance and a personnal hate of 3rd party Western games (remember the N64 had great Western games eg. Perfect Dark or Conkers Bad Fur Day) as well as the bizzare Japanese idea that companies must sit on money rather than invest it.



Around the Network

This reminds me of someone who said Pokken fighter would make the Wii U outsell the PS4. I thought he had to be joking, but it turned out he was serious.



Again Microsoft is targeting the same audience as Sony. If you own a PS4 why the heck would you buy an Xbox One? What is this must have game that people have to get on the Xbox One that they can't play on the PC or PS4?



HBninjaX said:
Zod95 said:

wolflink said:

wiiu will be second because smash and amiibo will disrupt the fkin market again
and 2015 looking better (about games) for wii u (zelda dont need to add more)

Amiibo has been launched already and WiiU continues to sell less than XOne.

Smash Bros is one of the very few significant WiiU games yet to be launched. Let me ask you a question: do you believe the list of WiiU games that will be launched in 2015 is stronger than the one from 2014 or 2013 or 2012? If not, then 2015 will be the poorest year for WiiU and thus it will sell even less than the mediocre results made so far. How can they win against a console that has been selling far better and that still has a very promising future? That's the big mystery.

No it hasn't.

"Introduced June 2014"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amiibo



Prediction made in 14/01/2014 for 31/12/2020:      PS4: 100M      XOne: 70M      WiiU: 25M

Prediction made in 01/04/2016 for 31/12/2020:      PS4: 100M      XOne: 50M      WiiU: 18M

Prediction made in 15/04/2017 for 31/12/2020:      PS4: 90M      XOne: 40M      WiiU: 15M      Switch: 20M

Prediction made in 24/03/2018 for 31/12/2020:      PS4: 110M      XOne: 50M      WiiU: 14M      Switch: 65M

wolflink said:
I dont know why you care much about shipments
those mean nothing (unless those sold out very quick)
but it is more important the Demand and the next gen graphics, budgets, cod an ac, people are on the ps4 train

wiiu will be second because smash and amiibo will disrupt the fkin market again
and 2015 looking better (about games) for wii u (zelda dont need to add more)
well i believe you want xone to be second the reality is that thats not going to happen and microsoft will close that division once and for all.


Smash won't disrupt the market any more than it did for the Gamecube and N64; this is simply not how market disruption works. If a title was to achieve something like that based on merits such as lifetime sales and attach rate (which has nothing to do with disruption either btw) then surely Mario Kart 8 would be the big potato here. Releasing yet another title in a long-running series with the exact same mechanics and core components will accomplish nothing in the way of disruption and, frankly, I thought that much was common knowledge for almost anyone who has an account in here today. It is painfully clear that you don't understand what disruption is and how it works, it sounds like the perfect deus ex machina for the Wii U's dire situation but it is quite simply an impossibility since the Wii U was never designed as a disruptive product at a base level.

Amiibos? NFC devices? A market that is already developed and thriving almost solely as a mobile/smart device all over the industrialized world? How will that happen? And wouldn't Disney Infinity and Skylanders already have disrupted the gaming market if NFC was the next big thing? The best selling Disney Infinity on Wii sold about 1.2 million on a console notorious for having a large casual userbase and which actually disrupted the market as a platform. Same goes for Skylanders; it is all been there done that, how will this revitalize the Wii U when it wasn't even that successful on the majorly popular Wii? This makes absolutely zero sense. Look at how Wii Sports Club (likely around or below 150k lifetime), Wii Fit U (slightly above 400k), Just Dance (about 300k) and similar titles are selling on the Wii U for a reality check of who the core customer base is compared to the Wii phenomenon.

"People are on the PS4 train" is a type of comment that always makes me laugh since it is more often than not said by fans of the Wii, which sold primarily on; you guess it, hype! When the Wii was the "it" console, this was brilliant strategy (it really was) and well deserved but now that tables have turned and the PS4 is the "it" console, consumers are stupid and have poor taste and the same goes for Sony.

How is 2015 looking better than 2014? They have something bigger than the combined might of Mario Kart, Smash Brothers and Donkey Kong coming? Zelda alone cannot carry the brunt of 2015's major software and the likes of Yoshi and Kirby were never as big, same goes for Metroid, Starfox and pretty much everything else they've had up their sleeve. Nintendo have quite simply painted themselves into a corner with the whole Wii U situation and they severely underestimated the extended development time needed for HD titles since they remained one gen behind hardware-wise in the 7th gen.

"well i believe you want xone to be second the reality is that thats not going to happen and microsoft will close that division once and for all."

Imagine that, sole subscription to reality (I know another user who uses phrases and wording such as that). And what are the signs of this becoming reality? If losing money was the main catalyst for such a thing; surely they would have killed the 360 prematurely since the whole RROD, disc-scratch and HDD errors cost them well above 1 billion dollars, not to mention bad publicity. We've seen MS actually taking steps and trying to improve their sales since they released the One (and they made tremendous efforts with the 360) and we've also seen MS just come off of a quarter posting 5.6 billion dollars in profits and recently been estimated to have the third highest market cap on the globe, which means that they have probably weighed the arguments for and against many times already and found that the company is doing so well overall and the Xbox investments have been so big already that it is simply worth it to try to carve out a position in what is still a very important market in the highest grossing part of the modern entertainment industry. It is their very struggle that proves that they are in it to stay; at the very least for the 8th gen.
This whole "MS will leave the race, Nintendo will disrupt the market again" nonsense is the only truly wishful thinking I've seen in this thread so far and going so far as to claim that you are sitting on "the reality" is utterly ridiculous.



Around the Network
Zod95 said:
HBninjaX said:
Zod95 said:

wolflink said:

wiiu will be second because smash and amiibo will disrupt the fkin market again
and 2015 looking better (about games) for wii u (zelda dont need to add more)

Amiibo has been launched already and WiiU continues to sell less than XOne.

Smash Bros is one of the very few significant WiiU games yet to be launched. Let me ask you a question: do you believe the list of WiiU games that will be launched in 2015 is stronger than the one from 2014 or 2013 or 2012? If not, then 2015 will be the poorest year for WiiU and thus it will sell even less than the mediocre results made so far. How can they win against a console that has been selling far better and that still has a very promising future? That's the big mystery.

No it hasn't.

"Introduced June 2014"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amiibo

Introduced, not launched.  When you launch a product it's available to purchase and use.



I'm willing to put my account on the line and say Xbox One 100% will take the 2nd place with Wii U distant 3rd.

I don't get how it can be thought of other wise.

Kinda boring though, all three console makers have their slot in almost certain lockdown.

Wow @ that poll results, neck and neck. I look forward to this thread being future bumped



https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png%5B/IMG%5D">https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/SliferCynDelta"><img src="https://www.trueachievements.com/gamercards/SliferCynDelta.png

HBninjaX said:
Again Microsoft is targeting the same audience as Sony. If you own a PS4 why the heck would you buy an Xbox One? What is this must have game that people have to get on the Xbox One that they can't play on the PC or PS4?

So sony will get 90% of sales and XB1 10%? Except that hasn't happened and isn't happening.

This excuse is trotted out all the time but doesn't explain how MS have sold more XB1's in 11 months than Nintendo have WiiU's in 23.

Contry to what you think, the only thing PS4 has over XB1 is slightly better multiplat graphics and good word of mouth, you and others make out like it's some gulf of difference between the two.

And now, Microsoft go into the holiday with a price advantage, more bundles, and more exclusives. That might be why somebody would want a XB1 over a PS4.



 

HBninjaX said:

Again Microsoft is targeting the same audience as Sony. If you own a PS4 why the heck would you buy an Xbox One? What is this must have game that people have to get on the Xbox One that they can't play on the PC or PS4?

Everytime a relevant multiplatform comes out, XOne sales jump. So far, the console has sold more than 6 million. Go ask them.



Prediction made in 14/01/2014 for 31/12/2020:      PS4: 100M      XOne: 70M      WiiU: 25M

Prediction made in 01/04/2016 for 31/12/2020:      PS4: 100M      XOne: 50M      WiiU: 18M

Prediction made in 15/04/2017 for 31/12/2020:      PS4: 90M      XOne: 40M      WiiU: 15M      Switch: 20M

Prediction made in 24/03/2018 for 31/12/2020:      PS4: 110M      XOne: 50M      WiiU: 14M      Switch: 65M

Ka-pi96 said:
Teeqoz said:
This reminds me of someone who said Pokken fighter would make the Wii U outsell the PS4. I thought he had to be joking, but it turned out he was serious.

Wait... what?


Yeah, I couldn't believe it either. I mean, sure people have been using niche games like HyWa, and Bayo to justify their predictions, but Pokken fighter? That's niche beyond anything I can fathom.

 

Someone quote this post when Pokken fighter causes the Wii U's baseline to double.