If X1 dropped to $299 this fall it would outsell PS4 1.5:1 minimum in NA. I expect it to outsell PS4 regardless in NA this fall. MCC is going to sell a lot of consoles and lets face it the PS4 fall lineup is extremely weak.
Edit: By fall I mean holiday season. Nov-Early Jan.
Compatred to what??? People dont just play exclusives and x1 doesn't have a good lineup this fall either, why does fall only matter?? Ps4 had MLB the show FF14 and tlou remaster what has MS had since Titanfall??? Such a BS post. Sony is smart to spread releases around.
Really? XB1 doesn't have a good fall lineup? How about Sunset Overdrive, Forza Horizon 2, and Halo:MCC vs Driveclub and LBP3. Its not even a contest which console has the better holiday lineup.
I picked the fall because that is by far when the most consoles are sold. The OP states at $299 the XB1 would still sell less than the PS4 and I'm predicting at $399 the XB1 will outsell the PS4 in NA this fall, which means it not outselling the PS4 at $299 is ludicrous.
i think the year itself gave us a pretty clear perspective what consumers wants, and i don't think x1 will be on top of their list this holiday season
forza is not a system seller and the 360 version wont help the x1 either..
MCC is a remaster, not a sequel or must have, must play, halo fans already played them, some will buy for the online, nostalgia and it will make a bump, but not that bump you're expecting
for sunset we have the titanfall example, that was an fps and didn't do miracles the x1, so it even can do great in metacritic, but i dont think there will be much people hyped for it (new game/franchise).
there isn't anything that impressive this holiday for neither consoles, but multiplats, hype and desire for the product will give the PS4 a confortable edge this holiday..