By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Should Yoshi's Whooly world be a 3D game? 3D is dead on Nintendo consoles? Game looks amazing though.....

NintendoPie said:
When did 2D supposedly become casual?


Well, 2D games are more casual friendly because of simple control schemes. When showing games to people without any experience, usually their biggest issues is with the 3D concept of moving with the left stick and controlling the camera at the same time with the second stick. It's more confusing for them in games with 3rd person view (since it makes more sense in 1st person).

Usually, non-experienced players learn way faster platform games, 2D shooters and fighting games. 3rd person 3D games generally result in peope moving with the stick and simply ignoring the camera at the point it becomes unplayable (or simply stop moving to correct the camera).

Edit: Racing games are 3D, but usually casuals don't have issue, probably because it is similar to driving a real car. In the end, the problem is that 3D 3rd person games simply aren't like moving in the real world (like a FPS is). You can face a direction and the camera can face the opposite one, an unnatural behaviour.



Around the Network
spurgeonryan said:
AZWification said:

Would a 3D Yoshi game even turn out well?


With the power of the Wii U? I do not see why not. They were masters of 3D back in the days of the N64. What changed?

A 3D Yoshi game wouldn't work, but I just can't my finger on why it wouldn't work!



                
       ---Member of the official Squeezol Fanclub---

It looks beautiful to me and the co-op option make sit very appealing to play with the wife.



No, it's great as it is.



You have to keep 2D alive.

I was sooo looking forward to cooping yarn style during the holidays... Ninty...



@Twitter | Switch | Steam

You say tomato, I say tomato 

"¡Viva la Ñ!"

Around the Network
Mystro-Sama said:
spemanig said:
Their unhealthy obsession with 2D is a huge reason why they're failing. If all the 2D games the released and planned to release where their 3D variants, they'd sell way better. Leave 2D to handhelds.


3D would cost way more. They're probably just looking to make a quick buck off this and the Kirby game which kinda looks like shit to be honest.


3D games sell more consoles. No one is buying a Wii U for Yarn Yoshi, Clay Kirby, and Donkey Kong Country. Many people would for a 3D open world Donkey Kong in HD, a 3D Kirby game, or a 3D open world Mario.



spemanig said:


3D games sell more consoles. No one is buying a Wii U for Yarn Yoshi, Clay Kirby, and Donkey Kong Country. Many people would for a 3D open world Donkey Kong in HD, a 3D Kirby game, or a 3D open world Mario.

So is that why New Super Mario Bros. consistently outsells it's 3D Mario counterparts?



Honestly... I think a 3D game would kind of ruin the series.



NintendoPie said:
spemanig said:


3D games sell more consoles. No one is buying a Wii U for Yarn Yoshi, Clay Kirby, and Donkey Kong Country. Many people would for a 3D open world Donkey Kong in HD, a 3D Kirby game, or a 3D open world Mario.

So is that why New Super Mario Bros. consistently outsells it's 3D Mario counterparts?


It doesn't "consistantly outsell 3D Mario." One NSMB outsold the Galaxy games. That's it. SM3DW isn't a true 3D Marios and even so, it's only been out for a few months. SM3DL outsold NSMB2. 2D Mario would never have sold as much if it wasn't for the Wii casuals who already had a Wii. 2D Mario would never have sold as much as Mario 64 or Sunshine on their respective platforms.



RolStoppable said:
I take it, 3D refers to games where you wander around and don't confront death very often.

Zelda, Hyrule Warriors, Bayonetta 2, Captain Toad Treasure Tracker and Xenoblade Chronicles X are clearly 3D games, are they not? Don't freak out over Nintendo making a few 2D games.

And no, 2D games such as this aren't cheap and easy to make. If they were, then third parties would rush to make those games.


No they wouldn't, because no one would buy them, as exemplified by every 2D game on the market that isn't called Mario or Donkey Kong.