crissindahouse said:
No, I did the math for this case so don't compare it with 15-20% African Americans or whatever. It was particular about this survey and the 4% unemployement rate since you were the guy who said that "many" companies wouldn't be in that list and this is simply wrong. Most would probably not even change their position. Not sure if you even read what I wrote. I even said that you are right that this survey isn't 100% accurate because of that but you can still expect almost the same result if you would switch 40 of the 1000 people. I used Sony as example because this thread was about them and Nintendo and Sony got a high 40% or around 400 votes so that they could expect to lose more votes as most others in this ranking if Sony would get less votes from unemployed people. But even they would lose only 16 votes if we would take the average loss they could expect and if not only one unemployed would vote for them. All I tried to explain to you was that you are wrong when you say that many companies wouldn't be in that list if 4% of the voters would have been unempoyed. Even the companies at the end of the list wouldn't have problems to stay in the list. If only every fifth vote was a "Yes" for a company then this company will only lose around 8 "Yes" votes if you have to replace 40 of the 1000 voters because only 8 of 40 or 200 of 1000 voted with "Yes". And this only if not only one unemployed will vote for this company. And it is very unrealistic that companies who aren't in that list would get more votes from unemployed since there is no reason for employed to vote less for a company unemployed would like to vote for. |
You're very hung up on the math here. Get math out of your mind....
If you survey 999 African Americans out of 1000 Americans, your results will differ than surveying 999 white Americans out of 1000 Americans - this is despite one group of people being a minority. This isn't rocket science. This is just plain common sense.
The survey doesn't represent Japan as a whole. It only represents 1000 people somewhere in Japan. Opinions differ from region to region. Even if unemployment is 4%, that is still over 5 million people. 1000 out of 5 million unemployed people will still give a different result than 1000 out of 5 million employed people.
In regards to your point. Yes, many companies wouldn't be there if the unemployed were counted. Stop using the survey's numbers, because the numbers are already bad.