I give it a solid 9 and it would have been a 10 if they started on time, didn't have the audio problems, and that $499 price left a deafening silence in the room that people thought it was $599 all over for a sec. Amazing press conference. Could have been better with a few slight things.

They didn't address the concerns that people had on the console. 1.

Oh, and a number

Objectively: 8
Subjectively: 0*

*6 if I could play games on it

I'd probably give it a 4. I might make a positive and negatives list.

It was a very good E3 presentation from Microsoft, it was so much more than I expected.
The only bad thing was the price, but for what you get, the price is actually very decent.

So I give a 9/10 for this presentation. It really set the bar high, I wonder if either of the two others can top them...

8/10

Spark looks amazing!
Titan looks good
It is probably going to cost at least $1000 here... DX

I give it a 1/10 for being the first Conference.

Now to actually watch the show and (hopefully!) add at least 6 more points to my total!

Not sure why people want to see more Japanese games.

Metal Gear Solid V
Crimson Dragon
Dark Souls 2
D4
Dead Rising 3 (somewhat)

Looks pretty solid to me.

Sorry, but Sony will beat this, and I'm still predicting that Nintendo will "win" E3, and they're not even having a fucking conference. But that ND tomorrow.........................yup.

Lots of games shown...no more Points system = GOOD

No pricing/Kinect options...no clarification about all the recent controversy = BAD

They did a lot better than I thought, I for sure thought the recent bad buzz would derail their strategy completely. Still a little reassurance about the DRM, used games, always on fiasco might have helped with their image.