guess which game will sell more

Calm down, not everything is a dick measuring contest. 

Wow. I guess it was too early for a new pokemon in USA.

Personally, I think it's just that it's a DS game releasing over a year and a half into the 3DS's life. People were moving on a couple of weeks after Black and White. There is no real desire for any more DS games.

They need to do a lot more than that. All their trailers since the E3 reveal have been lame Halo Waypoint type vid docs, its not going to buid up hyppe and get millions of views. 

not sure what you are all talking about because overall preorders are over 50% ahead of reach at the same time and we all know that they will start to advertise a hell out of it in few weeks with the forward unto dawn "movie" and stuff like that.

with reach, it started 8 weeks before release and preorders exploded, i expect microsoft to do it also like that this time at least for usa. i never saw reach advertisement in germany, let's see if it will change for halo 4.

btw:

21. Aliens: Colonial Marines (X360) - 24 - 1,310 - 62,057
22. Far Cry 3 (X360) - 14 - 1,310 - 61,021
23. FIFA 13 (X360) - 4 - 7,964 - 53,311
24. Medal of Honor: Warfighter (X360) - 8 - 3,835 - 53,156
25. Dishonored (X360) - 6 - 2,692 - 49,336
26. The Last Guardian (PS3) - N/A - 53 - 47,170
27. Transformers: War for Cybertron 2 (X360) - N/A - 2,173 - 45,922
28. God of War: Ascension (PS3) - 28 - 1,509 - 44,780
29. Ratchet & Clank: Tools of Destruction and Ratchet & Clank: A Crack in Time (PS3) - N/A - 4,282 - 44,452
30. Medal of Honor: Warfighter (PS3) - 8 - 3,128 - 44,195
31. NBA 2K13 (X360) - 5 - 5,615 - 43,849
32. Tom Clancy's Rainbow 6: Patriots (X360) - N/A - 259 - 43,263
33. Transformers: War for Cybertron 2 (PS3) - N/A - 2,979 - 42,316
34. Persona 4: The Golden (PSV) - 9 - 22,547 - 42,193
35. Sly Cooper: Thieves in Time (PS3) - N/A - 664 - 41,983
36. Far Cry 3 (PS3) - 14 - 571 - 41,860
37. FIFA 13 (PS3) - 4 - 4,917 - 39,368
38. Aliens: Colonial Marines (PS3) - 24 - 172 - 39,184
39. StarCraft II: Heart of the Swarm (PC) - N/A - 757 - 38,940
40. Dishonored (PS3) - 6 - 1,955 - 38,629
41. Tekken Tag Tournament 2 (PS3) - 2 - 2,768 - 37,198
42. The Last of Us (PS3) - N/A - 991 - 37,081
43. NBA 2K13 (PS3) - 5 - 5,189 - 36,494
44. XCOM (X360) - N/A - 1,363 - 35,583
45. Who Wants to be a Millionaire: 1st Edition (Wii) - N/A - 127 - 34,522
46. Dead or Alive 5 (PS3) - 4 - 2,317 - 29,373
47. XCOM (PS3) - N/A - 1,069 - 28,882
48. Metro: Last Light (X360) - N/A - 261 - 28,559
49. Dead or Alive 5 (X360) - 4 - 2,226 - 27,780
50. Prey 2 (X360) - N/A - 170 - 27,592

Source: VGChartz

to be fair it's sniper989 who decided to compare the two games.

He was saying how well it did by comparing it to Halo. He didn't try to imply that persona was going to outsell it, or try to troll anyone. Zane's comment had a slightly different tone.

Ya but isn't that what a "dick measuring contest" is. Sure he wasn't being a jerk about it like zanewane was. But he was trying to showboat the preorders by comparing it to a different big game. I do agree that he wasn't trying to imply persona will outsell halo, obviously, but there is a reason he compared it to halo 

I feel really bad for dishonored. It looks like it's gonna be a great game but not many people are preordering. I can't say much because I haven't either, but I will in the next couple weeks. I don't know if it will be able to reach the top 20 for both ps3 and 360, but the 360 might. Hopefully if it gets good reviews people will start buying it.