I still love the Final Fantasy games that I always loved. Most of the ones on your list, that is. However, I can not call myself a fan of FF anymore, as I'm beyond being giddy for a new FF being announced or a trailer being shown or preordering the game - all because I think FF13 is unholy trash and the biggest gaming disappointment of my life. Many share the first part of my feelings (trash), and many think that FF is on the ropes these days, as it, in my eyes, went from a franchise that you could buy without hearing any opinions or reading reviews (or as much as seeing footage), to a hit-or-miss affair, mostly miss. I will enjoy the good ones as well. I will just treat the series with extreme caution from now on. Extreme.

You know me and you know I know better than to trash the legacy of the whole series. But SE is doing it in my stead, and it's an endangered legacy.

Sony fans get pretty crazy over a bad score.

Final Fantasy easy. The most divided and confused fanbase will continue to be stupid with each new entry being regarded as the worst in the series.

I think the sony fans are a little bit more crazy.

I know you Xen and that's why your comment struck me as odd. I know a lot of people were utterly dissapointed with FFXIII. I myself, in retrospective didn't enjoy it as I used to enjoy a FF game especially because for a long stretch it didn't feel like a FF game. 

But those kind of feelings are not new. FFVIII suffered a massive fan rage because of the lofty expectations that FFVII had created and for many it signalled a downward path for the series and then FFIX came along. FFX also suffered quite a bit of rage because it departed from established mechanics that every FF seemed to have set in stone, like the absence of a world map and the actual beginning of the linear gameplay that FFXIII is very loathed for (plus it spawned FFX-II), and then FFXII came along, which is not only the highest rated FF game, it's also the return of the series's amazing story and plot from FFIV/V/VI days (and it could have been much better, had they stuck with Basch as the main character). 

What I'm saying is, the FF series, in the past 15 years has suffered these repeating cycles of rage/percieved or actual bad quality and then they pull off a much better game and the series looks to be back on track. 

Endangered legacy, being on the ropes, getting stale, every kind of adjective you could find, has been repeated over and over again for the past decade and a half, just as much as The Fantasy is back, a true RPG marvel and so on. 

One game should not be used as the sole judging stick for an entire series, especially not one that has proven that there's trully no two similar games in it's entire legacy. If FF continues to do poorly and the series continues in a long streak of bad games (as in FFXIV and FFXV being as bad or worse than FFXIII) then your words will be completly true, but if FFXIV manages to bring back the quality we expect from a FF game, then the cycle will repeat itself again.

But, but, but......8/10 is a good score!

I hope for it - but I absolutely don't count on it. vXIII (I can hate on KH's story, but Nomura can make games, and make them extremely well) and, to a lesser extent, Type-0, in my eyes, are its last hope(s) - XIV is terribad, as you know, and XV is far far away. A rapid descent in quality has been pretty much the trademark of SE's games on consoles this gen - and I don't expect that to change anytime soon, as they're still very intent on shoving more of FFXIII into the mix.

I admit you're a better man than I am, though ;)

If it's this site, then easily Uncharted. The Sony fanbase are the majority, are more vocal, and will be more upset I'd imagine.

A more interesting question I think, would be how do you think the fanbase of each game would react if the game got such a score?

Reactions can vary from posters who question the said sites credibility, posters who call into question the integrity of gaming journalism and criticism, others who will simply ignore the reviews and others still who have such an attachment to review scores they may have a complete meltdown. Then there's the trolls who will pick up on the poor review and propagate the negative information in it just to feed the flames.

Fun stuff.

Let me make a correction, my previous statements should be FFXV and FFXVI, I forgot that FFXIV has already been released in the form of a MMORPG and I don't count it as a true part of the series (on par with FFXI) since it's a whole different genre (that would be like saying WoW is the continuation of Warcraft III and part of the series). 

I agree with you, the grand majority of their console releases have been poor quality, the only quality game has been The Last Remnant which unfortunately was smeared with a lot of technical issues. In counterpart, their handheld run this gen has been on par with the quality of previous gen console games. The perceived descent of quality in the home console department is probably due to some poor decisions made by the executive staff, mainly the president Wada, which to be fair, hasn't had a lot of good decisions. 

If they can learn from this generation and apply the same amount of quality on the home console department as they have done on the handheld department, then I can see their good games coming back. They have the skills and human resources to do it, it's just a matter of applying them correctly. 

Their handheld efforts have been brilliant - from CCFFVII to Type-0 (demo's great!)... they should get some of those guys to work on the home consoles.

TLR is kinda to be expected - wasn't it made by the team behind SaGa?