By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - American Atheists' 9/11 Memorial Lawsuit Crosses the Line of Decency

@thismeintiel

It is late, and I am tired so I will keep this brief. I am not going to pick apart all your arguments tonight save the first one. No you cannot call the United States a Christian Nation. Firstly that is derogatory to all non Christian citizens. So you ought not do that out of simple decency. Secondly the United States government has made itself crystal clear about this terminology. No the United States is not a Christian nation.

@Rath

Weird though it may sound it is true. There are Atheist organizations for supporting their views, and they do indeed have leadership. Being a Atheist does not make one passive about their beliefs. At the time Ellen Johnson would probably have been a good candidate seeing as she was president of the American Atheists organization. What I personally find weird is the notion that you would bring religious leaders to ground zero in any official capacity in the first place.

To my way of thinking you can always kiss Gods ass on your own time rather then on my dime. Which is what our old friend Bush did with that stunt. It wasn't about the country it was about stroking his own damned ego. I wasn't too happy about his self absorption in asking the troops to pray for him either. What a fucking dick.

Anyway ask a silly question, and get a silly answer. Please learn to use a search engine in the future. This literally took me all of five seconds to find. Would it really have been that hard to do for yourself. I am nodding off now good night.



Around the Network
kitler53 said:
melbye said:
As an atheist i say they should get over it.


also an atheist, also think they should get over it.  america ought to be about respecting everyones right to religion -- christians/whatever respecting me and me respecting them.  it's not about trying to ignore religion, it's about everyone acknowledging everyone else in a respectful way.  


this is a great post. I agree with all of this.



I think the Atheist are just so tired of 'God' and 'Religions' being shoved at them all the time. Religious wackos put it in the pledge and on money - places religious references clearly do not belong. And are now trying to re-write history and say that George Washington prayed before crossing the Delaware and that Thomas Jefferson was a Christian. Even the author wrongly claimed that both Christmas and Easter have their roots in Christianity!

Some of us, myself included, get so tired of Christians that bully everyone, then cry foul when they don't get their way. Most Christians don't even know that Sunday is not their holy day as defined by scripture. ( it's Saturday. )

Why not put the cross in the Christian Church that is right next to ground zero. Wouldn't it make more sense to have it in a Church and not a governmental building.

That seems like it would make everyone happy.





 

Really not sure I see any point of Consol over PC's since Kinect, Wii and other alternative ways to play have been abandoned. 

Top 50 'most fun' game list coming soon!

 

Tell me a funny joke!

Dodece said:
@thismeintiel

It is late, and I am tired so I will keep this brief. I am not going to pick apart all your arguments tonight save the first one. No you cannot call the United States a Christian Nation. Firstly that is derogatory to all non Christian citizens. So you ought not do that out of simple decency. Secondly the United States government has made itself crystal clear about this terminology. No the United States is not a Christian nation.

@Rath

Weird though it may sound it is true. There are Atheist organizations for supporting their views, and they do indeed have leadership. Being a Atheist does not make one passive about their beliefs. At the time Ellen Johnson would probably have been a good candidate seeing as she was president of the American Atheists organization. What I personally find weird is the notion that you would bring religious leaders to ground zero in any official capacity in the first place.

To my way of thinking you can always kiss Gods ass on your own time rather then on my dime. Which is what our old friend Bush did with that stunt. It wasn't about the country it was about stroking his own damned ego. I wasn't too happy about his self absorption in asking the troops to pray for him either. What a fucking dick.

Anyway ask a silly question, and get a silly answer. Please learn to use a search engine in the future. This literally took me all of five seconds to find. Would it really have been that hard to do for yourself. I am nodding off now good night.

Was that ask a silly question get a silly answer directed at me?

Because if so the fact that there are atheist organisations does not make the idea of an representative of atheists any less stupid. Atheists are not at all a homogenous group unlike the major religions. I know that there are atheist organisations, I personally do not think they really represent anyone apart from the members of their own organisation.



I'm an atheist but I don't give a fuck about this stuff, those people should shut the fuck up



Around the Network
thismeintiel said:
sapphi_snake said:
thismeintiel said:

Well, regardless of what Obama thinks or wants, this is still a Christian nation. Some may be in the minority, but they just need to get over it. No one is making you go to the memorial and visit the "cross." No one is forcing you to bow down and pray to it. So, man up and move on with your life. Yet another example of a vocal minority trying to push its beliefs and values onto the majority by abusing the legal system. Personally, I don't even believe Jesus died on a cross, but I also don't give a shit what other people have come to believe. Wish more people could be like that instead of whining.

The US  isn't a Christian nation, and using tax money for this venture is abusing people's rights to freedom of religion.

Uh, yea it is.  The vast majority of its citizens are Christian, so therefore it is a Christian nation.  Of course, we allow any to come here and practice whatever faith they want without prejudice, as it should be.  And don't even bring up maybe using a few thousand to transport this structure that brought hope to many, when we have a govt that wastes billions every year.  And not having it there because a very small minority don't believe in it would be the true offense against freedom of religion.

No, that doesn't make the US a Christian nation. In order for the US to be a 'Christian nation', Christianity would have to be the official state religion of the US, Christianity would have to be in control of all institutions and the US laws would have to be based in Christianity. The US has no official state religion (something which is forbidden by your constitution), the state institutions are secular, and the Constitution is based on common law and influence from European philosophers. If the US were a Christian nation, then it would to be similar to Saudi Arabia, which is an Islamic nation: Islam is the official religion, every institution and every aspect of life is controlled by Islam, Sharia law is instated (which is based directly on the Quran and Sunnah). The only country in the world that can be described as a 'Christian nation' is the Vatican (which isn't even a real state).



"I don't understand how someone could like Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky, but not like Twilight!!!"

"Last book I read was Brokeback Mountain, I just don't have the patience for them unless it's softcore porn."

                                                                               (The Voice of a Generation and Seece)

"If you cant stand the sound of your own voice than dont become a singer !!!!!"

                                                                               (pizzahut451)

thismeintiel said:
sapphi_snake said:
thismeintiel said:

Well, regardless of what Obama thinks or wants, this is still a Christian nation. Some may be in the minority, but they just need to get over it. No one is making you go to the memorial and visit the "cross." No one is forcing you to bow down and pray to it. So, man up and move on with your life. Yet another example of a vocal minority trying to push its beliefs and values onto the majority by abusing the legal system. Personally, I don't even believe Jesus died on a cross, but I also don't give a shit what other people have come to believe. Wish more people could be like that instead of whining.

The US  isn't a Christian nation, and using tax money for this venture is abusing people's rights to freedom of religion.

Uh, yea it is.  The vast majority of its citizens are Christian, so therefore it is a Christian nation.  Of course, we allow any to come here and practice whatever faith they want without prejudice, as it should be.  And don't even bring up maybe using a few thousand to transport this structure that brought hope to many, when we have a govt that wastes billions every year.  And not having it there because a very small minority don't believe in it would be the true offense against freedom of religion.

"As the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion,—as it has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion, or tranquility, of Mussulmen,—and as the said States never entered into any war or act of hostility against any Mahometan nation, it is declared by the parties that no pretext arising from religious opinions shall ever produce an interruption of the harmony existing between the two countries."

 

Treaty of Tripoli, unanimously ratified by the Senate in 1797. The founding fathers did not believe that America was a Christian nation.



While that is undeniably stupid to try and block the lump of steel being included. I would have thought Christians would be the ones trying to block it, after all I know if I believed in Christ I wouldn't want Jesus's calling card attached to such an atrocity, I mean someone might think he was trying to claim responsibility...







don't kill me



@TheVoxelman on twitter

Check out my hype threads: Cyberpunk, and The Witcher 3!

scottie said:
Player1x3 said:
sapphi_snake said:
Player1x3 said:
scottie said:
Player1x3 said:

 Just as Easter and Christmas, though Christian in their roots

Haha, why repost this crap? If they don't know anything about religion, why should we listen to their ramblings?


christmas is a christian holiday, is it not? or does some other religion celebrate birth of christ?

Jesus was actually born in the summer (August, I believe), and most biblical scholars agree with this POV. What you today call Christmas was a pagan holiday which christians hijacked because people didn't wanna give up celebrating it. Christmas is part of christianity's 'pagan heritage'. Lot's of people today associate it more with Santa Clause and giving and recieving presents rather than with the birth of Jesus.

i know jesus wasnt born in december and i know 25th december was a date for a pagan holiday but thats all that's pagan about christmas - the date on which is celebrated. The rest is all christian.And by rest i mean the whole point of christmas - birth of christ. and christmas is far from secular holiday. as for santa, people (who are older than 8) do know the true meaning of christmas, its just that media, retailers and big corporations try to bring the materialistic sid of christmas really hard, and they are doing a pretty good job at it


The name 'yule' from yuletide is Norse

The gift giving was taken from the Romans

 

I oculd go on. christmas has pretty much nothing to do with Christianity.

except one small insignificant thing: the reason why its even considerd a holiday and the reason why its brought up in western world: the birth of christ



sapphi_snake said:
thismeintiel said:
sapphi_snake said:
thismeintiel said:

Well, regardless of what Obama thinks or wants, this is still a Christian nation. Some may be in the minority, but they just need to get over it. No one is making you go to the memorial and visit the "cross." No one is forcing you to bow down and pray to it. So, man up and move on with your life. Yet another example of a vocal minority trying to push its beliefs and values onto the majority by abusing the legal system. Personally, I don't even believe Jesus died on a cross, but I also don't give a shit what other people have come to believe. Wish more people could be like that instead of whining.

The US  isn't a Christian nation, and using tax money for this venture is abusing people's rights to freedom of religion.

Uh, yea it is.  The vast majority of its citizens are Christian, so therefore it is a Christian nation.  Of course, we allow any to come here and practice whatever faith they want without prejudice, as it should be.  And don't even bring up maybe using a few thousand to transport this structure that brought hope to many, when we have a govt that wastes billions every year.  And not having it there because a very small minority don't believe in it would be the true offense against freedom of religion.

No, that doesn't make the US a Christian nation. In order for the US to be a 'Christian nation', Christianity would have to be the official state religion of the US, Christianity would have to be in control of all institutions and the US laws would have to be based in Christianity. The US has no official state religion (something which is forbidden by your constitution), the state institutions are secular, and the Constitution is based on common law and influence from European philosophers. If the US were a Christian nation, then it would to be similar to Saudi Arabia, which is an Islamic nation: Islam is the official religion, every institution and every aspect of life is controlled by Islam, Sharia law is instated (which is based directly on the Quran and Sunnah). The only country in the world that can be described as a 'Christian nation' is the Vatican (which isn't even a real state).


you know, greece is an official christian nation, and none of the bolded stuff is the case there