Halo, being that it has the name halo in it and it's a remake of the original for 40$.

Halo CE Anniversary LTD 7.5 million
Uncharted 3 LTD 6 million

halo cea will outsell uncharted 3 most likely.

Halo

The xbox hasn't ever had any big time remakes released for an accurate judgement on sales potential. It seems obvious to think that it should sell at least as well as odst, but odst came after two years of no fps halo, while halo reach will actually be competing with the remake for sales being only 1 year old when the remake releases. If microsoft decides to include beta invited for halo 4, then it will probably end up outselling it.

Anyway my predictions are it will be a tie. Both will have LTD sales of 4.8mil. Because while halo has a chance to sell 7mil+, theres also the chance that few people want to buy a remake with so many other fps competing with it and it sells as few as 3mil, while Uncharted 3 is pretty much guaranteed to sell over 4mil unless naughty dog does something very very stupid with the game.

I really don't know. With the quality of Halo games getting worse and Uncharted 3 seem to be looking real good its hard for me to predict. If I really have to predict I will say Halo just for name.

Is halo ce really a big deal?? I thought it was just a quick cash grab that only the most hardcore halo fans would fall for. I expect it to sell less than ODST. With all the great games coming out are people really going to run out and buy a remake of a 10 year old game?

I never took into account the fact that odst had reaches beta. Which id say accounted for 1 million sales. I think halo ce will do 5 million lifetime.

Halo CE-make will be $40 and have a new map pack for the Reach multi-player so it isn't really competing against Halo: Reach. Plus it adds 4 player co-op and better graphics to a fan favorite...so I think it will sell well. Also I noticed the consensus is that UC3 will sell 6 million. What have the other Uncharted's sold?