By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - 7th Gen HD Battle - Which E3 was worse 360 or PS3?

 

Which was worse?

X-Box 360 106 71.62%
 
PlayStation 3 42 28.38%
 
Total:148
mchaza said:
Michael-5 said:
mchaza said:
I would have to say MS was worst because SONY had PSV. I would have to say that if SONY didn't reveal the PSV in jan this would of been an epic e3.

PSV and Bioshock and 3D TV were the highlights of the SONY press conference

But having watched the Ubisoft before hand i have to say that they were better because they had Mr caffeine who was face palm entertaining.

Only comparing PS3 to 360. Are you saying 360 was better then PS3?

I feel this poll will get a lot of pro Sony votes because people can't read...


MS would be better because despite being Kinect announcements and Halo 4 they had some new annnouncements, SONY announced all there games before E3. 

Even then, I still think some of the Kinect games for 360 are cool. However I probably won't get one, rather save $100-$150 for a next gen system.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

Around the Network

I have a smartphone for gaming on the move. So songs conference was horrible for me. Ps3 had nothing of interest for me. Imo 360 has a better varied lineup this year. And kinect looks amazing. Can't wait for star wars and fable. Also ruse looks awesome.
Best conference ms has ever done. More variety than any other company. Not just the same old controller genres.
Oh and the SioUX looks really bad. Is that really nintendos answer to kinect? MS MUST BE VERY HAPPY AIG NINTENDO RIGHT NOW.



Michael-5 said:

I think many people will agree that the Microsoft Press conference wasn't that special, and the PS3 portion of the Sony Press Conference was also fairly lackluster. Both focued a good amount of already announced upcoming titles, and both lacked new exclusive releases. Which do you think was worse? To make things simple:

Microsoft announced 8 new games, 6 adult themed ones (Halo CE Remake, Halo 4, Fable, Minecraft, Dance Central 2, and Kinect Sports 2), and talked about 4 other larges ones (Gears 3, Forza 4, Star Wars Kinect, Ryse..aka Project Kingdoms). Two games are Kinect exclusive. Total 10 games.

Sony Announced 4 new PS3 games (Dust 514, Sly Cooper, Starhawk, and God of War Collection), and talked about 4 other large titles (Uncharted 3, Resistance 3, InFamous 2, and Sorcery). One game is a Move exclusive. Total 8 games.

Both devs ignored multiple games.

MS ignored 17 previously announced Kinect titles, of which at least 5 are major (Project Dragon, Steel Batallion, Rise of Nightmares, Heavy Fire, Gears of War: Exile, etc). They also ignored XCOM and MechWarrior.

Sony ignored Agent, The Last Guardian and Twisted Metal.

So which developer was worse?

Well Minecraft and Dust 514 were both multiplat. I think MS ignored XCOM because it is now multi and the same may be true for Agent. I have no idea why MS ignored Mechwarrior unless it was pushed back for their next console, but no Alan Wake baffled me even more. I was sure Sony was gonna talk about Twisted Metal and The Last Guardian may be shown at TGS. MS may also be waiting for TGS to show their Japanese Kinect titles. As far as 360 vs PS3 I would have to say the 360 won because Sony was focused more on the Vita.



Love the product, not the company. They love your money, not you.

-TheRealMafoo

Goddbless said:
Michael-5 said:

I think many people will agree that the Microsoft Press conference wasn't that special, and the PS3 portion of the Sony Press Conference was also fairly lackluster. Both focued a good amount of already announced upcoming titles, and both lacked new exclusive releases. Which do you think was worse? To make things simple:

Microsoft announced 8 new games, 6 adult themed ones (Halo CE Remake, Halo 4, Fable, Minecraft, Dance Central 2, and Kinect Sports 2), and talked about 4 other larges ones (Gears 3, Forza 4, Star Wars Kinect, Ryse..aka Project Kingdoms). Two games are Kinect exclusive. Total 10 games.

Sony Announced 4 new PS3 games (Dust 514, Sly Cooper, Starhawk, and God of War Collection), and talked about 4 other large titles (Uncharted 3, Resistance 3, InFamous 2, and Sorcery). One game is a Move exclusive. Total 8 games.

Both devs ignored multiple games.

MS ignored 17 previously announced Kinect titles, of which at least 5 are major (Project Dragon, Steel Batallion, Rise of Nightmares, Heavy Fire, Gears of War: Exile, etc). They also ignored XCOM and MechWarrior.

Sony ignored Agent, The Last Guardian and Twisted Metal.

So which developer was worse?

Well Minecraft and Dust 514 were both multiplat. I think MS ignored XCOM because it is now multi and the same may be true for Agent. I have no idea why MS ignored Mechwarrior unless it was pushed back for their next console, but no Alan Wake baffled me even more. I was sure Sony was gonna talk about Twisted Metal and The Last Guardian may be shown at TGS. MS may also be waiting for TGS to show their Japanese Kinect titles. As far as 360 vs PS3 I would have to say the 360 won because Sony was focused more on the Vita.


I did not know XCOM went multi-platform, and I feel you may be right about Agent. Rockstar won't ignore half it's market for a large scale game like this.

I feel the same way about E3 as you, it's as if more games were ignored then talked about.

Sony skipped The Last Guardian, which I agree with likely go to Tokyo Game show, but MS skipped Project Draco, Steel Batallion, Rise of Nightmares, and a slew of great Kinect games. Will they also be Tokyo game show?



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

badgenome said:
Why on Earth do you keep referring to Heavy Fire as a major Kinect game? It's a $20 piece of shovelware, and it's even on Wii and PS3 - two systems where you presumably won't have to ride an invisible horse to shoot, a la yesterday's Ghost Recon showing.

I did not know that, only included it as major because it has a September 30th release date.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

Around the Network

PS3 won, if only barely.
Res3+U3+Sly:Thieves+Starhawk beat Halo:CEA+Halo4+Minecraft in my eyes.

Also, Michael, you forgot to include Starhawk.



Xen said:
PS3 won, if only barely.
Res3+U3+Sly:Thieves+Starhawk beat Halo:CEA+Halo4+Minecraft in my eyes.

Also, Michael, you forgot to include Starhawk.

No, I included Starhawk, look again, but I found out Dust is multiplat so I have to remove that.

BTW, I notice you included UC3 and Res3. Do you have no interest in Gears, Forza, or Ryse?



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

PS3 get no real new Games at this e3 besides of the Sly Game and Xbox 360 get Halo 4, Halo HD, Minecraft, Witcher 2 , Dance Central2, Kinect Sports 2 and a bunch of other Kinect Games and many new Xbox live Games. I think if you only compare the Xbox 360 and the PS3 than Xbox 360 really was far ahead and get far more new Games.



Michael-5 said:
Xen said:
PS3 won, if only barely.
Res3+U3+Sly:Thieves+Starhawk beat Halo:CEA+Halo4+Minecraft in my eyes.

Also, Michael, you forgot to include Starhawk.

No, I included Starhawk, look again, but I found out Dust is multiplat so I have to remove that.

BTW, I notice you included UC3 and Res3. Do you have no interest in Gears, Forza, or Ryse?

Must've missed it... sorry man.

Dust WAS on the 360 as well, but was announced as exclusive to the PS3 by Sony... regarding Gears/Ryse/Forza, no, not really. No interest whatsoever in Gears, pretty much anything Kinect, and Gran Turismo 5 keeps my racing needs in check. Two hugeass racing sims are just a bit too much for me.



So this is a serious thread?

lol, let me tell you exactly why MS failed epic at E3.

Hear me out now....

MS only reveals everything at E3, you guys say this yourself, don't you? Now Sony spent 1 hour or so on PS Vita at E3 so ignoring that is a massive fail on your part since if Sony didn't talk about PS Vita they would have talked about the PS3. Its simple.

Sony is not going to sit on its a** for the rest of the year, they will be revealing games throughout the year so as far as I am concerned I am not worried. They revealed a big game like Uncharted 3 at VGA last year and starhawk could have been easily revealed at E3 but they didn't. Resistance 3 at gamescom last year as well.

Its a simple thing. We are not going to get anything out of MS anywhere except E3. Sony meanwhile, doesn't take E3 that seriously. Overall presentation is obviously going to be more important in this case. Where MS will obviously have higher expectations since they do reveal big stuff at E3 and nowhere else.

You are talking about Halo? Again, we have seen how many Halo games this gen? Halo 3, ODST, Reach just last year, and now a remastered Halo along with Halo 4, 5 and 6 in the future. That makes it at least 5 halo games this gen. Oh WOW what an unexpected announcement.

That is excluding Halo wars as well.

They also showed every title they showed last E3, like GoW 3, Forza 4, Ryse (they haven't still announced a date for this or an year), so predictable its ridiculous.

Here's the prediction for the next E3 of MS, spoilers if you are excited for it:
MW4 or the next CoD
A couple of multiplats.
Ryse.
Kinect stuff.
Alan Wake the next.

Halo 4.
Halo 5 and Forza 5 have a good chance.
And maybe something else to end it all. A new Xbox console maybe.