Forums - Gaming Discussion - PSN vs XBL which is better?

PSN vs XBL which is better?

PSN 187 40.22%
 
XBL 206 44.30%
 
SAME 34 7.31%
 
obama saved or created 465 million jobs 36 7.74%
 
Total:463
Ronster316 said:

LIVE currently winning the poll despite PS3 fans heavily outnumbering 360 fans on this site.

The proof is in the pudding folks.

LIVE is just THAT DAMN GOOD...!!!!!!!!


yes because beinga fan of something is going to change your opinion.



Being in 3rd place never felt so good

Around the Network
zgamer5 said:
Ronster316 said:

LIVE currently winning the poll despite PS3 fans heavily outnumbering 360 fans on this site.

The proof is in the pudding folks.

LIVE is just THAT DAMN GOOD...!!!!!!!!


yes because beinga fan of something is going to change your opinion.


it has in the past. Easily changed polls, but eh that is neither here nor there. 

The 360 community is rather low here, compared to wii or ps3. Most people who would be fans of ps3 would vote for ps3 and vice versa its the neutrals that are interesting, and the neutrals seem to be voting for 360.



 

Bet with Conegamer and Doobie_wop 

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3879752

d21lewis said:

*cracks knuckles*  Okay.  I've had a good night's sleep.  I'm refreshed and ready to post.  I'm currently logged in to both Xbox Live and the PSN in my game room so I'm not going to post anything unless I see it first hand.  Both of my consoles are connected to the same TV with PS3 connected to HDMI 2 and Xbox 360 connected to HDMI 3.

  • First off, let's shut Blackbuster Critic up.  He complained about Xbox Live having ads.  It does.  Normally (but not always), the ads are either contests where you can win MS points, free wallpapers, or gamer pics.  There's no "video of a car driving" and shit like he says (*edit* well, I'll be damned.  I clicked on one of the ads and there was a part were I could watch a video of a car driving.  I guess I was wrong.*).  And I'm logged into the PSN as we speak.  Ads.  Some pertain to PSN content (which I don't count).  And then theres the "All new Ford Focus" ad, the "MLB TV"  right there on the front page.  People in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.  There's also an ad for the movie Black Swan on both the PS3 and Xbox 360.  I don't hold this against either system because, like most of these "ads", it's telling users what content is available ON THE SYSTEM.
  • Netflix.  Both consoles offer Netflix.  On the 360, you can actually see which movie your friend is watching and you can join them.  Both of you can watch the same movie at the same time and your avatars will be sitting in a theater together.  You can talk to them.  In fact, when you log into Netflix (or any game), the console will tell you "friends watching Netflix" or "Friends playing Street Fighter 4" and with the touch of the guide button, a list of friends and what they're watching will appear.
  • The PS3 browser:  It was great like the Wii browser, initially.  It's in dire need of an update.  I used to use both browsers a lot but now, even sites like VGChartz don't work on it.  Try going to last.fm on it.  It won't run the content.  Try going to youtube.  It will take you to "youtube XL" (aka the mobile version of youtube).  Try going to myspace.  You can't even look at a profile.  ESPN on Xbox 360 isn't a website (espn.com).  It's ESPN.  You can watch videos on demand, live events, etc.  Heck, even if you have Kinect, you can just tell the TV "Xbox, ESpn, play video 6, fast forward, play" and it will do all of those things with the clarity of DirectTV.  You guys seem to think that Twitter, Facebook, ESPN, and Last.FM are just the websites.  It's not.  They're like Aps.  I will admit, I don't have a Facebook account (did I mention I had a crazy GF?) but myspace will NOT WORK AT ALL.  Besides, who in the hell has high speed internet and no PC?
  • On Xbox Live, multiple accounts can log in at once.  If I'm playing two player split screen RE5, both of us can log in, get achievements, message our friends, etc.  On the PS3 (with the exception of Little Big Planet), I haven't been able to do that--and even then, I'm not logged in.  It just gives me my trophies when I DO log in later.  My PSN friends don't know I'm online.  I can't access my friends list.  Nothing.  I'm just a guest in somebody else's (usually, my daughter) profile. I play split screen a lot.
  • Messaging:  Yes, you can send your friends messages on PSN.  I can send friends messages and Voice messages on Xbox 360.
  • Friends:  You can see who you've played with on both consoles.  I can REVIEW who I've played with on XBL.  I can prefer somebody if we had fun.  I can block somebody if we didn't have fun.  I can report somebody if they did something I didn't like.
  • Friends Part 2:  I can compare Achievements with a friend without having to manually sync trophies.  I can see what games my friends are playing (like the PSN) but it will actually tell me what's going on in their game.  Instead of it just saying "d21lewis, Little Big Planet", it will say "d21lewis, Madden 2011, fourth quarter, 28-7" or tell what my score is in a game, or how many times I died.
  • Friends Part 3:  I can see my friends' profile.  Not just their avatar pic (and there are hundreds and of avatar pics to choose from--not just a few like the PS3 offers.) but their detailed profile.  You don't just type in a sentence.  You type in a whole profile about yourself (if you want to).  It may include where you live, what you like, or whatever.  Plus, not only can I see my friends list, I can see my Friend's  friends list!!
  • You have Gamer Zones so that if you're just playing for recreation, you can avoid those hardcore types.  If you're a family gamer, you don't have to worry about those crazy users.  If you're really intense, you can play with other intense, professional gamers.  You can pick the kind of gamer you play with.  There's also "TrueSkill" that takes into account how good of a player you are based on the games you've played to match you up against a similarly skilled player.
  • Every single solitary arcade game on Xbox live has a demo.  All of them.  You can try before you buy.  If you like it and buy it, it unlocks instantly.
  • Every single arcade game (and most other games) have leaderboards.  I can see at a glance which one of us is better at HexicHD, Geometry Wars, or whatever when I choose the game.  It's right there on my dashboard.
  • Indy Games and Game Room:  Super cheap games that cost about a dollar.  You talk about your cell phone games and your simple yet addicting games--There's hundreds of them available on XBL!!  And Game Room sucks.....but it has 100% authentic old school games for old school gamers.
  • Videos:  If you buy a movie or a TV show from the PSN and you delete it, it's gone forever.  You just lost your money.  I learned that first hand when I deleted a bunch of movies from my HDD a year ago (even made a thread about it.).  Why did I think I could just re-download my movies?  Because, on Xbox Live, if I buy a movie or a TV show, I can just re-download it for free.  It blew my mind.
  • Cross Game Chat:  Why the hell would I want to talk to somebody not playing the same game as me?  Because they may be on the dashboard trying to get into the same game as I am and I can talk to them as soon as they log in.  Because I may be watching Netflix and they may be playing a new game I want to know about.  Because we're friends and I want to talk to them.  No matter what they're doing on the 360, I can stay in touch with them.
  • Video Content:  You know how the PSN has Qore?  360 has Inside Xbox.  It has Major's Minute.  It has The Kinect Show.  It has IGN Strategize.  It has the OXM (official xbox magazine) report.  It has Xbox 101 (videos about xbox questions).  It also has some Xbox specific programming like The Guild.  It has Internet Videos.  I can watch MSNBC, the Today Show, and the NBC nightly news on my Xbox instantly, in HD, right now.
  • Music Marketplace:  Yeah, I know there's sites on PSN that will let you download illegal MP3's directly to the console.  I've done it.  XBL has music videos, last.fm(as I mentioned before), a gamestore for music games like Rock Band, and Dance Central, top 10 lists, and more.  Plus, with the Xbox (not an Xbox Live feature but I'll toss it in there), any music saved to your HDD can be used to replace the background music in ANY game.  I played Limbo with the Silent Hill 3 soundtrack.  I may put the Super Mario soundtrack that I got with Super Mario 25 Year Anniversary Edition as the bacground to Braid.  It's awesome!
  • Xbox 1 and Xbox 360 games:  Right there, ready for download.  Yeah, there's a few full fledged retail games available for download on the PSN.  There's a TON of full fledged retail games available for download on Xbox Live.
  • Xbox 360 lets you install any games (and there is a performance boost--I have a game that took about 20 seconds to load suddenly load in five seconds when installed--I hate to say it but it was Onechanbara Bikini Samurai squad.....).  Plus, I can download while the console is turned off.  Only PSN Plus users have that option.
  • Gaming with fame:  Almost weekly, there's an event where real stars pick a specific game and play it on Xbox Live.  It's featured on the community calender.  Game developers get into the act, too.  Add them to your friends list before the event and you can play their game with them.  There's also dedicated family nights, specific game nights, ladies night, and stuff like that.
  • Online performance:  This is purely annecdotal but I'll put my hand on the Bible.  I played a ton of games on Xbox Live without a hiccup.  There's been a few times where somebody "got disconnected" when I was winning in SF4 but that's rare.  I have yet to play a game on the PSN (in all honesty, I've only played Super Street Fighter 2 HD, Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2, Little Big Planet 2, Little Big Planet, and Killzone 3) without some major problem connecting, getting disconnected, or some lag.  There's even people on this site who couldn't even play with me for some reason or another.  I don't have that problem with Live.  Maybe it's different for you.  This is my experience.
  • Patches.  Be honest, PSN users.  Patches are a bitch.  Blame it on internet connection or whatever.  My 360 is sitting six inches away from my PS3.  Updates to PS3 games take anywhere from a few seconds to a couple of hours.  360 updates take anywhere from a few seconds to several seconds.  The only time it's taken minutes is when the whole entire dashboard got upgraded.  For this reason alone, I've NEVER played Uncharted 2 and MGS4 online.  I just couldn't wait that long.  When I got LBP GotY Edition, it took HOURS before we could play it.  Same goes for my nephew.  He got Smackdown, Madden, and NBA2K11 for Christmas.  I wanted to help him get the free DLC that came with Smackdown.  We spent half the day updating his console and games.  Tell me this is just us.  This NEVER happens on XBL.
  • When I play on Xbox Live, EVERYBODY seems to be into the game.  We all have headsets.  Both consoles have similar sound quality.  I use a set of Turtle Beach PX21 earphones when I play (highly recommended) for both the PS3 and 360.  Sometimes, when I play on PS3, it seems like I'm the only one with a headset.  It's not a feature of Xbox Live but providing everyone with the means to communicat is a big plus in Xbox Live's cap.
  • Both consoles provide their free content and stuff.  I got the movie Stranger Than Fiction for free from PSN.  I got episodes of South Park for free from XBL.  I got Ragdoll Kung Fu for free from the PSN.  I got Dash of Destruction, Harm's Way, Crash Course, Aegis Wing, Hexic HD, Carcossone, and Undertow for free from XBL.  PSN Plus users can boast a ton of other free content, too.
  • Every single game on Xbox 360 has Achievements.  There's games (like MGS4) for PS3 that don't have trophies.  For that reason, I don't bother with trophies at all.  It just seems like it isn't accurate.

That's it.  I think everything I posted is true. If you see something wrong, tell me and I'll try it on my PS3 (ID: d21lewis).  If I made a mistake somewhere, I'll gladly apologize for it and correct it.  Like I said, both my PS3 and 360 are turned on right now.  I didn't type anything I didn't see.  I don't have PSN , though.

I have a friend named Samuels at work.  He plays PSN.  He could care less about these features.  He just wants to get online and play.  PSN is a good fit for him.  He has a PS3.  I have a friend named Muai.  He plays Street Fighter on a professional level (been in several tournaments).  He owns a PS3 and a 360.  He only plays online games on the 360. I have a hard time finding anybody that owns both that doesn't prefer XBL.  Maybe it's not worth $60 to some people but for me, it definitely is.  My satellite costs me $90 a month.  Netflix costs me $10 a month.  My car costs me $100 in gas a week.  XBL costs $5 a month.  I can deal with that.


Excellent post.

So much in here that is taken for granted that just isnt there on PSN. 

The reason?  LIVE was always an integral part of what the 360 was going to be.  PSN is a hotchpotch of tagged on functionality. I doubt much of what LIVE can do is even possible on PSN, otherwise it would have happened already. The requirement to sync trophies is a bit of a giveaway... it will never be real-time in certain community aspects.



I'm not really here!


smroadkill15 said:
deskpro2k3 said:

they all say LIVE is good, but they dont know why!?!?1

it must be hypnotism.

I can think of plenty of reasons why XBL is better. If you want me to list them I can, but please don't make me waste my time trying to prove a point mostly everyone agrees on.   

look at the poll dude



AussieGecko said:
zgamer5 said:
Ronster316 said:

LIVE currently winning the poll despite PS3 fans heavily outnumbering 360 fans on this site.

The proof is in the pudding folks.

LIVE is just THAT DAMN GOOD...!!!!!!!!


yes because beinga fan of something is going to change your opinion.


it has in the past. Easily changed polls, but eh that is neither here nor there. 

The 360 community is rather low here, compared to wii or ps3. Most people who would be fans of ps3 would vote for ps3 and vice versa its the neutrals that are interesting, and the neutrals seem to be voting for 360.


yes ps3 fans would vote for ps3 but their are many people who are ps3 fans but they also enjoy and play on both systems, so they woudnt be biased.

the results areant that surprising, as any one who says that psn is better then xbl is delusional, that is without taking into account the price.



Being in 3rd place never felt so good

Around the Network

live has better communication features for gaming and thats it nothing else what soever. if there is something better i would like to know?



...not much time to post anymore, used to be awesome on here really good fond memories from VGchartz...

PSN: Skeeuk - XBL: SkeeUK - PC: Skeeuk

really miss the VGCHARTZ of 2008 - 2013...

Xbox Live > PSN

PS3 > Xbox 360 in every other category however :)



“Absolutely, we can do much more with it. I don’t know if we are even close to 50 percent of PlayStation 3’s power at this point,” said Asmussen about God of War 3.

ARE YOU KIDDING ME???

jhuff394 said:

Xbox Live > PSN

PS3 > Xbox 360 in every other category however :)


if live is better than psn

then it would have to be a case of what do you get for the money? what features come with live? all i can think of from what i have used is better cmms features for games



...not much time to post anymore, used to be awesome on here really good fond memories from VGchartz...

PSN: Skeeuk - XBL: SkeeUK - PC: Skeeuk

really miss the VGCHARTZ of 2008 - 2013...

smroadkill15 said:
deskpro2k3 said:

they all say LIVE is good, but they dont know why!?!?1

it must be hypnotism.

I can think of plenty of reasons why XBL is better. If you want me to list them I can, but please don't make me waste my time trying to prove a point mostly everyone agrees on.   


You already wasted your time.  Hypnotism my friend.



Poll results show how little difference XBL and PSN have XD when looking at: PSN being better / Live being better.

 

XBL is better but only by approximately 7,25%.


Sounds about right for me to be honest XD. That 7% isn't worth the money in my opinion.