I don't think anything I said was wrong. Gears 2 was a linear shooter that got me to unload nearly a whole clip into big bad guys using guns that were fairly similar to each other, then the cover mechanics and movements were slow and the melee combat was repititive. In comparison, Uncharted 2 was also a linear shooter that was fluid in it's movement and intereactions with the environment, the melee didn't get repititive, I didn't have to unload a whole clip into an enemy to kill him, the stealth mechanics changed the pacing to the gameplay and the platforming allowed me to move and shoot between areas as I felt fit. Gears 2 feels old now, it's gameplay, presentation and action scenes have been outclassed by other games like Vanquish and Uncharted 2. I really liked Gears 2, but I liked the first Gears more because of how fresh and new it was at the time and I don't think just 'more Gears' will satisfy me enough for the third game.
No offense, but as someone who plays this game every night, I have no idea what you're talking about.
What guns are similar to each other?
Movement is supposed to be slow. As much as people would like to dash around like a mad man, that's not what the game is about.
How is the melee repetitive?
I've played Vanquish. It's not my cup of tea. Quit preaching your opinions on other games as if they were facts.
I'm particularly baffled at the similar weapons comment. The only weapons that are similar are the lancer and hammerburst and that's just because they fire automatic rounds.