Is Miyamoto's take on new IP's right?

[Mnementh]

I agree with Miyamoto: different gameplay creates a new IP.
I agree with most posts here: different characters and story creates a new IP.

So in my opinion TLOU is a new IP, the first Uncharted was a new IP, as was the first Paper Mario or (long time ago) the first Mario sports game was.

For people saying Miyamoto cannot invent new characters and stories, all he can do is Mario: you all forgot Zelda, Pikmin or the Wii-games.

For people saying Nintendo has no new IPs: Dillon's Rollign Western, Pullblox, Freakyforms (all with new gameplay-ideas AND new characters).

For people talking about generic shooters: try some games of the range of 'generic shooters' and talk again.