This is a tough one...although MGS4 probably has the best character models in the business today, Killzone 2 and Uncharted 2 are a cut above...between these 2, it's honestly a very tough choice...what impresses me so much about Uncharted 2 is that there is hardly any loading in the game...the game just loads once when you start it up...that's it...no more loading and still such pretty graphics...it also has a superior art style to KZ2 and also dares to make use of colour...it also has a lot of good subtle touches, like the powdery snow and how Drake's shirt gets wet (gosh i still cant get over that)...Killzone 2 on the other hand has a lot more going on...so many enemies, huge environments, and the level of detail is astounding! The game does load a lot, but the level of detail more than compensate for that...i know we haven't really seen KZ2 in a colourful environment, but I'm sure that the game would look phenomenol if it took place off of Helghan...until that happens though and the game makes more use of colour, I say Uncharted takes the cake by a very very very tiny margin!

The character models in MGS4 still destroy the other two games though my friend. And when I say destroy I mean there is literally no competition.

OT - You named 3 out of maybe the top 10 best looking games (graphically). Killzone 2 is still the king of consoles IMO because I have never seen a game look that realistic before. From lighting, to texture, to character models, it is the best all around package. For me, Uncharted 2 falls right between the three that you listed. It stands out the most with its enviornments and lighting. The forest and snowy areas are what I am specifically referring to right now.

MGS4 is still the best game out of the three, and EVER!!!

Well, how do u judge the grafix of different games then that u might not have played? For example Crisis.

I think it's perfectly valid to judge based on videos in HD quality, cos as long as you compare video to video (and not video to actual hands on gaming) the comparison is fair between games.

killzone 2 definatly,that gun is just so sexy

uncharted 2 for me because the colours brings more realism than Killzone 2 and MGS4.

MGS4

The game with the best draw distance and most colors, which removes Killzone 2 and MGS4 already from the list. Uncharted 2 wins by default.

It's almost unanimously agreed that Uncharted 2 is the best looking console game of all time.

So I would go with Uncharted 2. MGS4 was too devoid of colour, and Killzone 2 looks fantastic, but I think Uncharted 2 looks better. Again, colours.

@Resonable, technical capabilities, I want to know who reigns in character models, environments, physics, color, overall graphics etc.

It's looking like Uncharted 2 to be number one and Killzone 2 close behind.

This is just what he wanted. a flamewar between PS3 fans.