10/10 better than last year

10/10. They did what anyone wants from a console maker:

- get great exclusives
- show footage of upcoming games
- some big announcements (MGS)
- showed a new very ambitious project (Natal - though I am not yet convinced on the quality, we have ways to go before seeing this thing hit the market I believe)
- and practically no bla bla about numbers and such

Let's hope Sony and Nintendo will follow suit!!

You've got to admit that for anyone who hasn't watched The Guild she comes across as some bizzare combination of geek and flake (which, I presume, is exactly what she's going for).  Having watched the guild though, it's just funny.  Uber-nerd-girl showing her social networking addictions on xbox.

a 9
i was very impressed with what they showed

8/10 It was ok, and I saw a few games I liked. Definitely not the best ever though.

8/10 the presentation itself was well put together but everything was expected apart from the Halo reach showing. I was most impressed by Splinter Cell which can be taken in a few ways.. I must say I thought a couple of their announcements such as facebook and twitter won't impact sales and Natal is too far away, I don't know why they showed it..

Overall I think it was about the same as last year in quality with all things considered.

To say that Project Natal is the same as the eyetoy would be to say that the PS3 is no different then the PS2.

I give them a 9/10 (leave room for Sony or Nintendo to have a higher score)iii, but right now I think that it was great. And aside from MGS, Halo Reach, and project Natal everything seems like it is Fall 2009 or Spring 2010.

I'd like to see something put up about when the mods think on the main page

8/10

the facebook/twitter part was the least interesting- but would probably get the most end use.

No huge surprises. But not disappointing either.