For me, the IR isn't accurate enough.  It's not more "immersive" to me because it still just works like a mouse.  You aren't pointing at where you want to shoot in most games, and even if a game calibrates it has accuracy problems.   Motion plus isn't going to change the IR controls.

I'm am not discussing quality, but gameplay!!! Jeez!!!

What?

The quality of a game is decided mostly by its gameplay, right? There's graphics, sound, presentation, and lasting appeal, but that's less important.

Now, all of the versions have the same lasting appeal, right? And you'd expect the PS360 to have better graphics, sound and presentation. Now, you're saying the Wii version has the best gameplay, and yet isn't the best version?

What?

Same here! So I'm not the only one. I hate the idea of FPS on the PS3 because the controls always make it so hectic, but on the Wii it makes it easier to handle.

I never liked dual analog even before the Wii. I would always play FPS on PC instead. There are a few games I made exceptions for because they interested me alot(resistance 2 is one). Also here we go again with the MP3 comparisons. MP3 is an Action-Adventure it is not comparable to Action games(Halo CoD). You could compare the interface because they are both first person, but anything else would be like comparing an Elder Scrolls game to Halo or Call of Duty. Also did any of you guys customize the control options or just leave it on standard settings?

No, that is not the case always.

well im not a shooter fan, i played shooters a bit in the past on the PC, therefore dual analog control was always a bit of a challenge for me, and to be perfectly honest i never been good in shooter games (especially console ones).

I really prefer Wii control in shooters (and CoD:WaW is really fun) its just more intuitive, but at the end of the day thats not the genre of my choice.

I love it when Wii fanboys (and yeah I've spotted at least 2 of them here) claim the superiority of the Wii controls in shooters.

In fact it might be even true, but it's always coming from guys who suck at playing FPS with normal controlers.

Just accept it that there are MANY gamers who could kick your asses in every FPS. (I'm not denying that the average Wii gamer is probably able to beat an average PS360 gamer)

It will be interesting to see what the control schemes for the next generation of consoles are. I can't see Sony and MS sticking with there current control schemes after losing this generation so badly to inferior hardware with innovative controls.

Actually aiming is more fun and immersive than aiming with an analog stick. The controls on the Wii for FPS are superior to dual analog. Play MP3, COD:WAW, or MOH: H2 on the Wii and you'll see if I'm right. You'll never want to play dual analog again. It's like trying to play a shooter with a single analog stick after playing with dual analogs. Get with the times you dinosaurs. :p