Yes, other remakes have had some element of success, especially in japan but none of those have been much more than a rehash of 2D elements (apart from the DS one), some using the same 2D from other games in the series (FF1/2 have been done on about 6 formats with basically the same gfx), this would take a fraction of the manpower and money that porting FFVII to the PS3 would. Even if they had the renders from the ps1 game, rerendering them in 1080p isnt going to be enough, it would still look old, unless they did soemhting drastic it wouldnt get anything but criticism.

The reason Square have rehashed so many of their previous 2D games is becasue its easy money , something that i dont think would apply to FFVII on the PS3. 

Not according to the best selling games of all time list.

SMB is not in it.

 SMB3sold 18 million in its lifetime.

NO MORE FINAL FANTASY REMAKES.... ONEGAI SHIMASU!!! Okay FFVII fine, but as long as it stays exactly the same as its PSX version, same story, same system, better graphics of course and better sound but the same tunes... then yes, It most definitely will wet my pants... But as soon as they start to change the battle system, scenario, just completely rip it apart... I'll rip SE apart! In matter of speaking...

*call me dumb*, what's FNC?

Right, the so called, long during project. You know, that doesn't really interest me. I liked Final Fantasy just to be Final Fantasy, a new game, with a new world, new story, new characters. Finished and then off to a complete other Final Fantasy game. It's not that the games go to one platform, but to different platforms, which bugs me the most. How far can a gamer follow the story if the games are split on different platforms, while you only own one of them?

that same french one leading iwth "SHOCK" popped up months ago, its not happening....as sad as that makes me.

Go tell that to gameinformer and wikipedia. I will be laughing at you when they announce FF:VII remake on the ps3 exclusively.

haha, game informer and wikipidia, the two most reliable places on the net.

As it was said in The Office "Anybody in the world can say anything they want on wikipidia, that's how you know you're getting the best information available"

 That list left out a game that was a pack-in title. Meaning it sold most of its copies while people were purchasing the NES. Just like how WiiSports will never end up on the list because you can only count copies sold in Japan.