Wow, looks like the community is divided straight down the line on this one.

It's gonna be a nail-biter.

Kart.

Kart FTW!!

Can you do brawl where you play locally with someone, but the both of you can play online from the one Wii console?

Yes.

I was hoping this wasn't an option, as it would have made my choice easier...

I prefered Mario Kart since it had more replay value.

But I thought you were a "fake gamer".

i would say brawl i think its a better game,but if you like mario karts more then get it,also yes you can play two people online from the same wii

 In that case: no. Better?

Why not just flip a coin? That's how I picked my college, my girlfriend, and my health insurance, and everything worked out okee-dokee there.