By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Which Is Worse? Overly Defensive or Overly Pessimistic

Tagged games:

 

Which Team Are You On?

Team "Nega is more tolerable." 3 23.08%
 
Team "Optima is more tolerable". 10 76.92%
 
Total:13

Both are annoying and shitty, but I hate negativity worse cos so much of gaming discourse now is just endless, obsessive hate and negativity and its so tiresome.



Around the Network

I'd say the former is worse since not being critical will just lead to things stagnating. I'd take a world full of overly harsh people than a world full of people that'll just accept something mediocre or even bad with no pushback.



Nega. Toxic positivity is still toxic, and has worse consequences.



Funny thing is, in like 2012-2019, I was actually a deeply pessimistic person, (ask anyone here who knew me back then) partly due to suffering from depression. (Unrelated to gaming, more due to life stuff) I was constantly being Mr Doom and Gloom.

It took getting cancer to teach me to look on the bright side, and now I'm much happier for it. Life's too short to be making yourself miserable by fixating on the worst that could happen.

I now can't stand those who are aggressively negative. Toxic positivity can be annoying and harmful as well, but the vortex of obsessive hate and negativity that social media algorithms have nurtured is far worse IMO.

Last edited by curl-6 - on 30 October 2026

Pessimism toward art is far more common and more off-putting than defensiveness. Because defensiveness is generally more harshly criticized while pessimism is often celebrated.

I'm OK with negative opinions. But badgering/trolling fans of The Last Jedi or Rogue One wherever they try to talk about it on the Internet because it doesn't fit your idea of what Star Wars is, calling yourself a "true fan" and speaking for the "true fans" is just obnoxious and pretentious.

Pessimistic entitled fandom in general is irritating: 'It was wrong of you to not cater to my specific wishes! I am a true fan of the original source material/older films/books/games' and then you'll have a bunch of other dickheads agreeing with Spartacus over there. It  turned fandom and communication with show creators/film creators/game creators into a cesspool, ruining it for everyone.

Also, these weird interpretive lenses where moral grandstanders pick an ideological or political topic and make it completely about that, very often with no actual basis in the topic → often these people go on weird, multi-post tirades about nebulous/vague abstract terms (‘libertard’, ‘woke’) and other dumb meme-culture shit, without actually making any sound criticism.

Yeah, fandom on social media would be worth the time if wasn't loaded up with a bunch of histrionics going on and on about things they claim to despise, yet can't seem to stop discussing.

Last edited by Jumpin - on 29 October 2026

I describe myself as a little dose of toxic masculinity.

Around the Network

Both discourses suck and both of them usually are based off console wars, but Nega is the worst. Optima actually enjoys his games and would not engage in such discouse if the Negas of the world stopped criticizing him for enjoying his games. Nega criticizes TotK for being too different and criticizes OoT remake for not being original. He knows he wants to complain, he just needs to find the reason why.



Imo, the worst part of Optimas statement is the negativity of other brands. Cut that out and I'm fine with what's said, even if I disagree. Nega to me just feels draining.

Personally I'd just prefer if people were generally less hyperbolic overall, honestly. Not necessarily neutral, just less extreme.



Doctor_MG said:

Imo, the worst part of Optimas statement is the negativity of other brands. Cut that out and I'm fine with what's said, even if I disagree. Nega to me just feels draining.

Personally I'd just prefer if people were generally less hyperbolic overall, honestly. Not necessarily neutral, just less extreme.

I'm not sure what it is about the internet, but it often feels like if something is good, then a very vocal minority will go to extreme lengths to make sure that people know that it is not only good, but the best there ever has been. Claire Obscur, Resident Evil Requiem, and Splatoon Raiders are three examples that immediately jump to mind, each rating among the highest games of all times based on MetaCritic user scores and such.

I mentioned this in my "The Soapbox Is Yours!" thread, but I do believe people really should not live chasing after emotional highs. It is nothing more than an unhealthy mechanism to cope with stress.



Optima, because fuck Grand Theft Asshole VI and fuck games that are just a code in a box.