What are some games that you fully acknowledge are deeply flawed and aren't for everyone but you love/play to death anyway? 

I don't really play most of the famous 'so bad they're good' games, but I do have some niche interests where the games that scratch the itch best are still pretty mixed bags. One such example is an indie game called Parcel Corps. It has mixed reviews on Steam and it's a bit thin and repetitive, but the mix of Crazy Taxi, Jet Set Radio, and BMX inspirations is still pretty fun and probably my most played game on two wheels at this point. 

Hbu? 

Onechanbara: Bikini Zombie Slayers has all the depth of a puddle and is incredibly stupid, but it's also mindless fun.

Hollow.

Ghost ship in space survival/horror FPS. Very predictable but good atmosphere (mostly). 

Outward

It has 67 on Meta, yet it sold more than 3M copies due to being fairly unique in what it does - exploration RPG that has survival/crafting mechanics, but only just so that it supports that focus on exploration, mixed with faction politics and somewhat Souls alike combat (though more punishing, since every exertion or lose of health is reducing your maximum stamina/health).

How much you carry is actually hindering your movement and efficiency, so dropping your backpack in combat is essential (which is risk cause it can be stolen by enemy). Map is there, but you have no idea where you are (no indicator), so you really need to pay attention to world and learn it.

When you "die" you wake up...somewhere, depending on who beat you, few days have passed (might be very important for some quests), and ususally without your backpack.

Did I mentioned local split screen coop?

Sure, it has lot of jank, and if I didn't know better, I would say it's definitely European made game (it's not, it's Quebec made), with lot of ambition, small team and somewhat questionable execution, but I guess that ambition and disregard for industry trends is exactly what made it so appealing to a lot of people, myself included,

Yooka-Laylee, only got 68 on meta but I enjoy it as one of the few modern collectathon platformers.

Spy vs Spy (2005) got 53, maybe the singleplayer isn't too hot but I really enjoy multiplayer classic mode lol.

Spyro Hero's Tail. Low 60's and while it has a very different feel to classic Spyro I think it's a decent platformer in its own right.

I'm pretty much a sucker for kart racers, even if they're not good. I played and 100%'d Shrek Smash n Crash Racing and Dreamworks Superstar Kartz in the last couple of years lol.

Yeah Yooka Laylee I can agree with, its pretty uneven and unpolished, but I appreciate it for its nostalgic qualities all the same.

Probably some old Dynasty Warrior game, maybe DW5, if I had to pick one right now. People used to complain about the simplistic gameplay and bad voice acting, but I was never bothered by them, because there was always the tactical level I was much more interested in, and back then, I didn't pay much attention to voice acting anyway. I'm not sure voice acting is still too important to me, although I do pay more attention to it now.

I should really visit the old Dynasty Warriors game at some point to see if the tactical level actually still holds up. I know it certainly doesn't in newer titles, but I've been wondering if it's just nostalgia or if the tactical side really was better back then.