I'm rooting for Astrobot on this one and I think it will have the better reception of the two. Sales wise however... I think Zelda will win.

I would love if Astrobot somehow turns into a big hit, though. Like I said, I'm rooting for it.

Going with Astro Bot for critical reception and EoW for sales.

Astrobot really deserves to win both.

Zelda both categories will destroy astrobot

Hm, Astro Bot would be no-brainer - if it was reskinned as Mario and launched on Switch. But PS fanbase (and every other, I guess) can be very tricky to predict when it comes to this type of games, so everything is possible when it comes to sales.

And when/if Astro gets received better, you'll blame them leftists and their evil agenda.

Zelda with sales, probably easily. Reception is going to be interesting. Wisdom looks really odd and goofy to me, but on the other hand Nintendo has never released a zelda game that wasn't very good to excellent.

Rooting for Astro in both categories but outselling Zelda with an install base of >140 million is going to be an uphill battle.

Zelda will get both, but I'm WAY more excited for Astro Bot right now.
Just waiting for the game and the beuatiful controller to ship to me next month!

Zelda for both categories and when it comes to sales it will not even be remotely close