Vodacixi said:
The Final Fantasy games was just an example. Sure, they have remastered music and... remastered sprites? I don't think that's quite the word, but whathever. My point is they are still old games sold on nostalgia at a very expensive price (especially the physical release).
If Square Enix was very successful withthat approach with a series much less popular than Pokémon... I think the course of action is very clear. They could follow suit and basically sell Gen 1-3 at 80 dolars with close to zero developement costs and obtain ridiculous amounts of money from the tens of milions sales they would make.
Or they could put them on NSO, which most of their Pokémon fans already have and make significantly less money.
|
Doesnt matter if they are old games, people can complain about Square Enix as much as they want, but at least they give more effort in their remasters and remakes unlike GameFreak who simply ported straight from Game Boy to 3DS identical copies of games.
Its not just remastered music and sprites
QoL features like Boosters which can alter experience gain, money gain and to turn off encounters is or a detailed map (which the original versions never had) which showed treasure chests and paths is a game changer and a great way to entice people who never played the older games or the series at all - great way to start the series too since you can customize your own difficulty when it comes grinding.
There's all sorts of other stuff they did which pretty much makes playing the NES and SNES originals (and the PS1 versions) pointless to go back and play again.
https://finalfantasy.fandom.com/wiki/Final_Fantasy_version_differences#Final_Fantasy_pixel_remaster_series
Anyways to go with sales and prices..
Whether the Pixel Remasters was a success is unknown because SE tends to make their expectations unreasonable - they sold a total of 3 million units between 6 games between the Switch, PS4, PC/Steam and iOS/android versions as of September 2023. They havent had any press release since.
https://www.gematsu.com/2023/09/final-fantasy-pixel-remaster-series-sales-top-three-million
Another thing to consider is the fact that you can buy the games separately so not everyone "Paid $80" - the entire collection goes for $75 , has been on sale once for $60.
Individually - Final Fantasy I PR and Final Fantasy II PR are $12 each ($9 when on sale) and III PR, IV PR, V PR and VI PR are all $18 each ($14 when on sale)
I would guess that III PR (because its the only 2D Remake of III), IV PR and VI PR are the ones that sold the most between the six games.
https://www.dekudeals.com/items/final-fantasy-i-vi-pixel-remaster-collection
Compare to your claim that Gen 1-3 for $80 would sell for millions....if it were true, they would have done it a long time ago - clearly there's a reason why they have not.
Pokemon Red/Blue/Yellow sold 1.5 mil copies (across 4 versions, 3 in WW and 4 in Japan) - the only known figure since its release. The games were being sold for $10 each on the 3DS back in 2016 (this was before the Switch existed and the 3DS had a high user count - also the games never went on sale unless you were lucky to find a physical retailer who sold them for less like Best Buy did for $7 each.)
https://www.ign.com/articles/2016/04/28/pokemon-re-releases-sold-over-15-million-worldwide
I cant find numbers for Pokemon Gold, Silver or Crystal's 3DS re-release anywhere so I'm assuming it flopped in comparison and which is the reason why they stopped making re-releases of the older games.
So either they'll release it on NSO as a way to entice people to join NSO (and to get people who unsubscribed to NSO to come back) or they wont do anything with older versions of games and just focus on mainline games, spinoffs and remakes like they been doing for the past decade.