That game is great. The narrative is a bit....off. But the gameplay is top. 

Only if you include performance in graphics, which nobody who matters does. 30FPS is acceptable in some games and in this particular case it was definitely not what made me quit the game.

Owned it once upon a time. It was beyond awful. Horrible gameplay. Stupid obtuse areas that tell you nothing how to progress. It's the game that makes me realize why the rest of his games have practically no real gameplay. Trying to hide how inept he is as a level and game designer.

Vectorman, Turok 2, can't think of one from PS2/GC/Xbox generation, Resident Evil 6, HellBlade.

Red Dead Redemption 2 immediately came to mind

I played Uncharted 1 through the Collection for PS4 and was bored to death with the repetitive gameplay. The story wasn't THAT interesting either (for me) but even being just the remaster of a 2007 PS3 game, I was quite impressed with the graphics and surely it must had been an amazing experience back then if only for the graphics.

Has no one mentioned The Order 1886? That's basically the poster child for this.

Naughty Dog games in general. Even going back to the Crash Bandicoot trilogy they just seemed kind of backwards in the gameplay department despite how good the visuals were for the time. It was basically taking Donkey Kong Country, moving the camera behind the character, and making the levels blander.

The Conduit. On a technical level it was probably the best-looking Wii game at the time, and the controls were perfection, but the level and encounter design really dragged it down. Too much of having to destroy pods or conduits on the walls, dealing with invisible mines, or those giant bullet sponge crab things. Online multiplayer was a blast with those controls though.

Fuck it,I'm going there.

Final Fight. Looked good on SNES but it's average to me. Esp after Streets of Rage, TMNT, Sengoku 2,X-Men, and more from that era. Capcom themselves had much better beat em ups in that era. Final Fight feels average next to those.

Realism in video games doesn't necessarily translate to fun in video games. I do agree that this game has a very realistic element (although let's be honest one person dragging a little girl around beating a room of 20 bad guys with guns one by one doesn't scream realistic to me). I'll take the original Metal Gear Solid on PS one. The game was stealth and realistic but the action was way faster than in the Last of Us.

Plus in the end the game sold well so it seems to me I might be in the minority with regards to my opinion. I'm just pointing something out I did not enjoy about that game to the point I thought it was best to watch the rest of the game on YouTube than beating it myself. 

I see no counter-argument, so I am right :3