Forums - Nintendo Discussion - Twilight Princess vs Skyward Sword

I prefer...

Twilight Princess 62 63.27%
 
Skyward Sword 36 36.73%
 
Total:98

@mZuzek Ah there was the excuse I needed to shove my ranking of these games down everyone's throats again.

I'd say neither TP nor SS is 'the worst' (indeed, as if that was "bad").

Among 3D Zeldas;
OoT > BotW > TP > MM > SS > WW



Around the Network

I've never played Skyward Sword. I thought Twilight Princess was decent, but not good enough for me to try Skyward Sword.



Ugh, here we go again.

SS > BotW > MM>OoT>WW > TP



The_Liquid_Laser said:
I've never played Skyward Sword. I thought Twilight Princess was decent, but not good enough for me to try Skyward Sword.

The two games aren't much alike, to be honest. But given the kinds of games you enjoy most, I think it's fair to assume Skyward Sword wouldn't be your kind of thing.



mZuzek said:
The_Liquid_Laser said:
I've never played Skyward Sword. I thought Twilight Princess was decent, but not good enough for me to try Skyward Sword.

The two games aren't much alike, to be honest. But given the kinds of games you enjoy most, I think it's fair to assume Skyward Sword wouldn't be your kind of thing.

Probably not.  The only thing that made Skyward Sword look interesting was the motion+ controls, but I'm betting it is not a beat em up game like Hyrule Warriors.



Around the Network
The_Liquid_Laser said:
mZuzek said:

The two games aren't much alike, to be honest. But given the kinds of games you enjoy most, I think it's fair to assume Skyward Sword wouldn't be your kind of thing.

Probably not.  The only thing that made Skyward Sword look interesting was the motion+ controls, but I'm betting it is not a beat em up game like Hyrule Warriors.

It's not quite a beat em up, no



Twilight Princess. No mandatory motion controls, better story, better dungeons, better atmosphere. A far more enjoyable experience in general.



Twilight Princess was nice, haven't played Skyward Sword yet because of forced motion controls (which I don't like). I still hope for a Skyward Sword Switch port.



Does Skyward Sword have Malo?  I rest my case.



My main issue with Skyward Sword is just that it is formulaic in its progression. It takes away the magic of the game. Visually and aesthetically and gameplay wise it was a joy. I just wish it hid its progression bones better.