By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics Discussion - Catalonia declares independence. Puigdemont free to roam Belgium.

 

Who do you support?

Spain 139 59.40%
 
Catalonia 95 40.60%
 
Total:234

In response to the updated title of this thread.

I don't think Puigdemont is here in Belgium to flee Spain, he's only here to discuss with people like him: ignorant separatists in the hopes of getting some momentum for his misguided independence bid. Unfortunately we have lots of those idiots in my country so it makes sense that he's here to gather some support. Though this is embarrassing for my country and already a political issue in the local news. Oh boy why did we have to be dragged into this?



Around the Network

I really hope this doesn't cause a diplomatic conflict between Spain and Belgium because we have a pretty good relationship, but so far people here is reacting negatively to the fact that the country may be giving Puigdemont assylum and the fact that his Belgium lawyer is the same that defended several ETA prisioners years ago.

Last edited by Goodnightmoon - on 30 October 2017

CrazyGamer2017 said:

In response to the updated title of this thread.

I don't think Puigdemont is here in Belgium to flee Spain, he's only here to discuss with people like him: ignorant separatists in the hopes of getting some momentum for his misguided independence bid. Unfortunately we have lots of those idiots in my country so it makes sense that he's here to gather some support. Though this is embarrassing for my country and already a political issue in the local news. Oh boy why did we have to be dragged into this?

clickbait is the only way us hard working journalists could compete with the big guys

Am i right to say that you don't really like nation states or nationalism? Or is it only in this context?

Last edited by fory77 - on 30 October 2017

Goodnightmoon said:

Barcelona today










Because all catalonia wants to leave.... right?

So, were 62% of teh people prohibited from voting?

How did 38% of the population get to decide for Catalonia?

Haven't paid attention to this ordeal, but those pics just remind me of Democrats protesting after Clinton lost. Trying to say that democracy doesn't work or something. You know, after a peacefull election was just held.



fory77 said:

clickbait is the only way us hard working journalists could compete with the big guys

Am i right to say that you don't really like nation states or nationalism? Or is it only in this context?

Well, as a philosopher once said "Patriotism is the love of your country, nationalism is the hate of the others"

Perhaps I should describe myself as a supra-nationalist in the sense that I prefer unions like the EU to nations. But nations exist and will be around for a long time so in that context I think that with all the nations in the world the situation is complex enough as it is without the need for regions to want independence and thus making things even more complicated.

This is even more important in today's world of globalisation and the internet where everyone can communicate with anyone all over the world. The notion of nations becomes blurry and not as strong as it used to be. It used to be that people from two different nations had nothing to do with each other, nothing to share (except hatred and war) but now all that stuff is making less and less sense, we share more and more, we talk as if there were no borders, we come and go and the borders are becoming irrelevant. So when a bunch of ignorant nationalists with no concept whatsoever of the world as it is today, want to create MORE borders, more frontiers, more separations, I tend to disagree with them in an absolute manner.

So I guess the simple answer to your question is I tolerate nations cause they are already the union of smaller groups, I tolerate them because one day I hope they will themselves unite with other nations to create a supra-nation like the European Union is doing, like the United States is. And in that state of mind I resent separatists like the Catalans or the Flemings in my country and I believe that Brexit is a monumental mistake due to a lack of vision of the big picture so to speak.

Last edited by CrazyGamer2017 - on 30 October 2017

Around the Network
irstupid said:
Goodnightmoon said:

Barcelona today










Because all catalonia wants to leave.... right?

So, were 62% of teh people prohibited from voting?

How did 38% of the population get to decide for Catalonia?

Haven't paid attention to this ordeal, but those pics just remind me of Democrats protesting after Clinton lost. Trying to say that democracy doesn't work or something. You know, after a peacefull election was just held.

The referendum was ilegal, it had no guarantees and the government advised not to vote because they were going to stop it, so the people that would have voted NO stayed in home. Right now we don't even know if the numbers the government of Catalonia gave are right and not made up, we do know however that some people voted more than once which already tells you how "serious" and "democratic" this referendum was, but even if the numbers were valid that would still mean that only a 38% of the adult population of Catalonia have said that they want to go, the rest may want to stay, you don't declare independence with only that, its highly unethic, but they did it anyways.

Last edited by Goodnightmoon - on 30 October 2017

CrazyGamer2017 said:
fory77 said:

clickbait is the only way us hard working journalists could compete with the big guys

Am i right to say that you don't really like nation states or nationalism? Or is it only in this context?

Well, as a philosopher once said "Patriotism is the love of your country, nationalism is the hate of the others"

Perhaps I should describe myself as a supra-nationalist in the sense that I prefer unions like the EU to nations. But nations exist and will be around for a long time so in that context I think that with all the nations in the world the situation is complex enough as it is without the need for regions to want independence and thus making things even more complicated.

This is even more important in today's world of globalisation and the internet where everyone can communicate with anyone all over the world. The notion of nations becomes blurry and not as strong as it used to be. It used to be that people from two different nations had nothing to do with each other, nothing to share (except hatred and war) but now all that stuff is making less and less sense, we share more and more, we talk as if there was no borders, we come and go and the borders are becoming irrelevant. So when a bunch of ignorant nationalists with no concept whatsoever of the world as it is today, want to create MORE borders, more frontiers, more separations, I tend to disagree with them in an absolute manner.

So I guess the simple answer to your question is I tolerate nations cause they are already the union of smaller groups, I tolerate them because one day I hope they will themselves unite with other nations to create a supra-nation like the European Union is doing, like the United States is. And in that state of mind I resent separatists like the Catalans or the Flemings in my country and I believe that Brexit is a monumental mistake due to a lack of vision of the big picture so to speak.

What i meant by nationalism is more a sort of ethno-linguistic nationalism, or if you prefer ethno-linguistic patriotism. I believe there should be an independent France wherever mainly French people live, an independent Bulgaria wherever mainly Bulgarians live... all with varying degrees of economic integration. The EU seems to agree with me more or less so far. However, as you say, they want to create a super state. Why? 

(Maybe just ignore this whole section) Why would/should a bunch of ignorant nationalists care about the endgame of globalisation, just give them what they want. In a stable, peaceful planet i guess globalisation is inevitable, so why risk all the unrest and instability to avoid a map changing? But back to the real world, i'm just gonna say it. It's not the end of history, we don't know what will happen. I just want stability, peace and a computer.

(couldnt find a place to put this and couldnt just delete it) nations will likely exist even in that future as there will always be some way to divide people into groups (religion, language, race, class ,ideology, geography, philosophy, gender even) 



VGPolyglot said:
Hmm, unless this can somehow gain traction for a socialist movement in Spain, I don't really have any strong feelings either.

You want them to end up like Venezuela?



Lawlight said:
VGPolyglot said:
Hmm, unless this can somehow gain traction for a socialist movement in Spain, I don't really have any strong feelings either.

You want them to end up like Venezuela?

No, I don't want a state that lies about being socialist.



CrazyGamer2017 said:
Goodnightmoon said:

They were gonna remove their powers because they were going to declare independence, pretty simple.

Kill their leaders? What? lol You are very out of reality here, I guess you are also one of those paranoic portuguese that believes Spain is still waiting for the right moment to conquer your country despite the fact that Spain hasn't give a fuck about it for centuries. Get the hate out of your eyes because is blinding you, PP is a horrible politic party but Spain is mostly an open, democratic and free country (rated 94/100 in civil rights byt Freedom House), nobody is gonna get killed by the government just for that.

Good luck trying to reason with that guy. I tried in vain...

So just sit back and be entertained by his contradictions. Like when he says that no one can decide what people should do but he keeps deciding in every one of his posts about how Spain should be broken up just cause he wants to.

In the end the important thing is that Spain is a democratic land where people are free to come and go as they please and have their opinions and it's a EU country and those ignorant separatists will not succeed in destroying the country. That's what matters

You are acting pitifully. I'm done bothering with you lot. Enjoy your echo chamber. It won't make you right.

Last edited by Nem - on 30 October 2017