By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics - Is it time to worry about Austria again?

 

Who should I vote?

ÖVP 16 12.40%
 
SPÖ 13 10.08%
 
FPÖ 39 30.23%
 
Grüne 16 12.40%
 
NEOS 3 2.33%
 
Other 4 3.10%
 
Don't vote 13 10.08%
 
Scoreboard 25 19.38%
 
Total:129

There's something wrong with islam is western society so the party that's against its advances would get my vote.

 

The BBC commissioned a poll on what UK muslims think and the results are shocking.  https://youtu.be/Dr_3BrE5Wqc

 

We need that in our society?



Around the Network
Kerotan said:

Well the jew hate,  gay hate and less respect for women is really worrying.  I just hope these Muslim kids growing up now have less of it then their parents from wherever they came from.  And if every generation after has less of it then eventually it will be gone.  

 

Now we have plenty of jew haters,  gay haters and men who don't respect woman from Europe too so it's not exclusively a Muslim problem. 

It is not exclusively a muslim problem, but the problem is significantly bigger among muslims.

And I'm sorry I don't think the decline from generation to generation is nearly big enough to solve the problem on it's own, especially with the amount of immigrants we have gotten lately and we risk getting in the future. Did you notice how many turkish descendants are supporting Erdogan? We are talking 3rd generation of immigrants in many cases! I have lost patience with the pasive integration tactic we have had so far. We have to keep the immigration from muslim countries at the minimal until we find solutions for the problems we already have. We have to make it absolutely clear to the people who move here, that the conservative islamic values they practice in the countries they come from aren't welcome here, and either you leave those discriminating ideas behind or you move to one of the countries where those ideas are the norm.



RolStoppable said:

I think you keep injecting other countries into this discussion or talk in a much broader sense when this thread is only about Austria and the Austrian burqa ban. We are talking about a country where a far-right party has had a consistently strong presence for decades, so when it comes to problems because of intolerance, it's not immigrants that Austrians have to worry about. We already have enough of our own people be such a problem.

What you keep missing about the Austrian burqa ban is that it doesn't only affect an estimated 150 muslim women who wear burqas, but also thousands of Austrians if the law is enforced as it is written. The main reason why I am against this law is not because I am left wing (I am not), it's because the law comes with utterly stupid consequences for Austrians and only exists to pander to simpletons who are scared that Islam could take over, so the primary goal of the law is that these simpletons don't become voters for the FPÖ.

It's paranoia to believe that we need laws to keep out ultra-conservative muslims or otherwise our whole society will be screwed eventually. Ultra-conservatives don't come here by choice to begin with, because they view our society as one of sinners. The only reason why such people move here is because they are out of choices. They wouldn't leave their home countries if there was no war. Once you understand the reason why ultra-conservatives move to Europe, you should also realize that a burqa ban isn't going to stop them. A burqa ban is a far lesser nuisance than what they face elsewhere and it only affects their women anyway, and women are second class and have no say in the matter to begin with.

But you would still have a problem with a burqa ban if it only did affect the 150 muslims, wouldn't you? Personally I would prefer that, but I get why they didn't do it that way, since they would have gotten in trouble with EU and UN if they did. The way they decided to do it might seem a little silly, but frankly, not being allowed to wear a shark costume is an insignificant prize to pay. They could probably enhance the law by allowing professional use of masking.

If you, by ultra-conservative muslims, mean muslims that defend stoning as a punishment for infidelity and such, then sure, it isn't a lot of those who would move to Austria (though those who come tend to become imams to poison the muslim public opion), but I mean it's not only the few ultra-conservative there is the problem.  I think it's bad enough with the muslims that think homosexuality should be illegal, don't you agree? Well in the UK (sorry for bringing in another country, can't find any statistics on Austria), litterally the majority of muslims think homosexuality should be illegal, let that sink in. 52% to be exact:

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/apr/11/british-muslims-strong-sense-of-belonging-poll-homosexuality-sharia-law

Only 18% answered that it should be legal. Also 23% want sharia law. Isn't that also Islamic extremism to you?

To be fair the UK has been notoriously horrendous with dealing with their parallel-society, the numbers are probably better in Austria, for comparison in Denmark it's 25 % of the muslims that think homosexuality should be illegal, which is still roughly a factor 10 more than the general population.

If we say the Austrian numbers are similar to the Danish ones, which probably isn't far off, then couple that with the fast increase in muslim population over the past 25 years or so, where it has become about 4 times as big (to about 8 percent in Austria), then it is not difficult to see why a lot of people fear an islamification of their country, and how can you deal with that? Allow less to come in and write laws that forces them to drop their conservative religious ideas. It is not true that they only come here because of war; Islamic State didn't chase them all the way up through Europe, they come because of the combination of a war in their country and because they want to flee to a country where they can get the best social benefits. They could easily settle down in Jordan or Lebanon for instance, where they could live by islamic culture, but they decide to go to europe instead, because of money and social benefits.



Youngest Chancellor ever?

 



I always thought Kurz was an SPÖ politician.... well that's how much I care about Austrian politics.

Btw. you forgot Pilz in your last post. Currently a bit over 4%.



Around the Network
Vinther1991 said:
RolStoppable said:

Supporters of the burqa ban fall into more categories than xenophobes and racists. One of them are the people in the parlament who use it as a defense to prevent the FPÖ from gaining more traction. Then there are the groups of ignorant or naive people that I mentioned in my previous post.

I am not sure what your point is. Right now it looks like you are an intolerant person who doesn't care about the people who would be affected by laws and at the same time gets offended that he is getting called out for it, hence why this discussion started in the first place. And that...

That is absolutely not true, there are no people I don't care about. It is you who constantly bring up the number 150, as if because they are few, they are not worth caring about. I legetimately think that a burqa ban can help some of these women integrate better into society, especially if other laws can help them get out of their ghetto and interact more with the native society.

RolStoppable said:

...can be seen here. Your solution to a nonsensical law such as the burqa ban in Austria is to introduce more headscratching laws. I've pointed out the estimate of around 150 women who wear a burqa in Austria, but you keep playing it up as a problem so severe that it necessitates the introduction of multiple laws. Ultra-conservative muslims who settle here are small in numbers and they have no chance to grow their ideas, because their family members are going to see our society and the rights that women have, so the daughters are likely to break free and the idea of the burqa will ultimately die with the old men.

1)So any law that is forcing muslim women to get out and interact with society is automatically headscratching to you? Is it headscratching to require that people attend meetings at for instance the city hall to get unemployment benefits. Is it nonsensical to require that they take a language class to keep their residence permit? There are a lot of reasonable ways to basicly drag them out of their houses and ghettos, against their husbands will if necessary.

But it seems that for you and a lot of other people on the left wing, it is so so terrible to require anything of the people who choose to migrate to our countries.

2)We are dealing with problems of the parallel-society we have created, muslims are overrepresented in crime statistics,  a lot more muslims have negative views on jews and homosexuals compared to the native people, and a lot more muslims treat women as inferior. Turkish immigrants are supporting Erdogan in abundance. The list of problems is massive, and a lot of it can be traced to the fact that we haven't made it absolutely clear that you have to adapt to western values when you move here.

Either you are blind to all those problems, or you lack the balls to come up with some solution for them, and instead you trash the people who do look for a solution and find one that is admittably flawed, could be it won't help as intended, but is definitely worth trying out, since we don't have any better. And yes sure, we do put a restriction on a human right that says people are allowed to wear whatever they want, but nobody are getting their lives destroyed because they aren't allowed to wear a burqa. Sometimes you need to create a minor problem to deal with a bigger one. And I think that a burqa ban doesn't only affect the 150 who wear a burqa, but it also sends a clear signal that we are against the mentality that women are not allowed to show any of their body to other men than their husbands, which could keep some of those muslims, who are nearly impossible to integrate, out of our countries.

1) It is headscratching for so many reasons, you literally have isis police officers who demand women to wear a burqa and then you have white christians who demand women can't wear a burga.  It is like a joke for the muslim community 'the muslim community is to hard for their women and don't give them freedom let's show them what's freedom by giving up the choice of what women may wear'...It is also headscratching because it ends up hurting more people than those 150*.   Let's face it, even if those 150 women lived alone, choose to wear a burqa, were working and were benefitting the society financially...the burqa ban still will exist because they fear the freedom that women may choose to wear a burqa.   The boys/teen males and some old idiots are basically creating the problems, a man who's wife can't wear a burqa will send her to a country where she can wear one and he stays here. 

 

2) That's also because people like to blow the numbers up I used the example of my city and a city like brussels before.  If you go into the rich neighbourhood Non muslims/Muslims teens have both a low percentage of coming into contact with the police or going to jail. While if you go to a poor neighbourhood in Brussels the White/Non muslims/Muslims etc have a way higher percentage of coming into contact with police/unemployment/going to jail. Considering most newcomers are coming from poor countries and are muslim it should not have been a surprise that they overrepresent the jail numbers.  I just wish people would try to make poverty go extinct instead of always repeating the jail numbers.  It is like saying 'White Male Christians CEO's in Hollywood overpresent the numbers of Sexual abusers compared to the Muslims CEO's' so Christianity is a problem and Male christians only want to rape women ;(.

The Jew hate has more to do with Israel and Palestina and it should also not be a surprise that when Israel does something the hate against jews spurs up. Just the same like after Pearl Harbor asian buddhists in USA were beaten up more frequently and even temples were burned down by Christians did not matter if they were Chinese/Korean/Thai etc;

The hate against Homosexuals is sad but surprisingly it was only 30 years ago when their were almost no muslims in Western societies that Homosexuals were beating up more frequently and were not allowed to marry. Anyway religious people always have a harder time to accept homosexuals but it is evolving in a good direction (as in more acceptance)

Accepting Western Values is always complicated because we have so many countries in Europe that basically have no muslims but where homosexuals almost have no rights or don't have the right to marry and so many other differences.






RolStoppable said:

I am always late with these things because I care so little about politics, but it has come to my attention that there are elections in Austria this Sunday. Some people may remember my thread from last year about the presidential election:

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=216193

This time a new government will be formed and things are pointing towards a coalition between ÖVP and FPÖ. The ÖVP is pretty much the Austrian equivalent of Merkel's CDU in Germany while the FPÖ's German equivalent is the AfD. These two parties have run the government before (only once, I think), but otherwise it has been a coalition between ÖVP and SPÖ with the only difference being who of the two had the higher share of votes and more say in the government. SPÖ is on a downward spiral though, plus ÖVP has been moving more to the right lately, so despite ÖVP + SPÖ probably still being possible, the ÖVP is much more likely to choose the FPÖ as their partner. At least that's what I've picked up from the little news that I paid attention to.

Here are a bunch of surveys from September that were conducted for major newspapers to give you an idea about the power levels of each political party in Austria:

28.9.2017 Unique research-Umfrage: 
ÖVP 33%FPÖ 26%SPÖ 24%NEOS 6%Grüne 5%Pilz 4%, Sonstige 3% 
(Befragte: n = 1000, Befragungszeitraum 25.9.-28.9.2017; für die Tageszeitung Österreich)

17.9.2017 IMAS-Umfrage: 
ÖVP 33-35%FPÖ 23-25%SPÖ 22-24%Grüne 7-9%NEOS 3-5%Pilz 3-5%, Sonstige ...% 
(Befragte: n = 1033, Zeitraum: 17. August - 11. September 2017, für die Kronenzeitung.)

11.9.2017 market-Umfrage (David Pfarrhofer): 
ÖVP 33%SPÖ 26%FPÖ 24%NEOS 5%Pilz 5%Grüne 4%, Sonstige 3% 
(Befragte: n = 814, maximale Schwankungsbreite +/- 3,4%, für die Tageszeitung Der Standard.)

10.9.2017 OGM-Umfrage 
ÖVP 33%SPÖ 25%FPÖ 25%Grüne 5%NEOS 5%Pilz 5%, Sonstige 2% 
(Befragte: n = 805, maximale Schwankungsbreite +/- 3,0%, für die Tageszeitung KURIER.)

Don't ask me what NEOS and Pilz are. Until an hour ago I didn't even know they were a thing. What's very important is that in early October evidence for dirty campaigning of the SPÖ came to light, so the party is expected to suffer in the election and therefore the above surveys are probably misrepresenting support for the SPÖ as prospective voters might be disgusted by the scandal and vote for a different party or stay at home.

Looks like dark times ahead for Austria. A burqa ban has become effective at the beginning of this month and to cloud its racist motivations, it also prohibits other ways of covering your face. Therefore, someone covering their face with a scarf during the cold months of the year can be punished with a €150 fine if the police deems the temperature as not cold enough. I am not joking, this is real.

So what's next for Austria in the near future is that there is going to be a referendum to join Germany. I don't want to live in the same country as vivster. I wish I was overexaggerating, but this isn't like the presidential election last year where a positive outcome was more probable than a negative outcome.

There is a referendum to join germany ? Ypu cant unilateraly decide that. We also have a say.



RolStoppable said:
Netyaroze said:

There is a referendum to join germany ? Ypu cant unilateraly decide that. We also have a say.

Wenn der Kuchen spricht, haben die Krümel Pause.

No matter from which angle you look at it we are the Kuchen. But I appreciate the sentiment. I knew Austria loved us deep down. 



RolStoppable said:

Yes, I would still have a problem with a plain burqa ban, because it punishes muslim women instead of their men who are the actual source of the problem.

By ultra-conservatives I refer to those who force their women to wear a burqa; I single out this group because those muslims only account for a small percentage of all muslims in the country. Stoning people for their homosexuality is an entirely different topic and as long as there are no reports of muslims acting violently against homosexuals in Austria, there's no real problem. Sure, there are people who think that homosexuality should be punished, but thoughts aren't a crime. You'd easily find Austrians who hold crazy beliefs, but as long as they don't harm others and don't call publicly for the harm of others, it's not something that requires measures to counteract the beliefs.

That's why I find the fear of islamification way overblown, because if I was scared of nutcases, I would have more reason to be afraid of Austrian citizens than immigrants. A number like 25% (going with your estimate for the sake of argument) of muslims thinking that homosexuality should be illegal isn't really scary when over 20% of Austrian's voters actively support a political party like the FPÖ.

EDIT: Early estimates after the end of the election put ÖVP at 31%, SPÖ 27%, FPÖ 25%, Neos 5%, Grüne 3.9%. So Grüne could be missing out because the threshold to get in is 4%.

How exactly is a burqa ban a punishment of women? I really don't see the big deal! I don't buy that they would just never come out, because that's not how society works, you have to come out sometimes, and then their men would have to learn to live with it.

There needs to be violence against homosexuals for you to see a problem??? What about the muslim homosexuals who have to hide their sexuality of fear of being expelled, or worse, attacked by their community?!

The parallel societies in every european country is so bad that even some of those who want to become part of the society don't dare to, out of fear of the reaction of their muslim family and community.

We need to remove the whole foundation for a parallel society, and that is done by enforcing laws, but you would apparently rather sit back and twiddle your thumbs and hope that the problems magicly disappear, while you simultaneusly yell 'racist' after those who try to find a solution. Or maybe you just don't care about any of this shit?

And yes, it is a shame that a party like FPÖ (which I am really not a fan of) has become so popular, but I guess that is what happens when the established parties have ignored all those problems for decades and are only now slowly beginning to look for solutions.



RolStoppable said:

@bolded: You spent all this time to talk about how muslims don't want to integrate, but then turn around and say that you don't believe that they would refuse to integrate.

And yes, there needs to be violence or a public call for violence for a significant problem to exist, i.e. a problem that needs to be acted against. A thought police isn't going to work and it is a crazy idea.

I can't shake the feeling that you have trouble to talk about Austria as you constantly drift off into talking about the UK and their situation. It's also not like the FPÖ has experienced a recent rise, it's a party that has been popular for decades because Austria is a country filled with people who are xenophobic. The burqa ban in Austria exists for no other reason than to pander to xenophobes; it has already been pointed out by multiple people in this thread that the anti-burqa law is stupid and the only counter-argument you could provide is that you don't believe that muslims would refuse to integrate in society, which ironically contradicts the rest of the stance you have towards muslims.

I didn't say that muslims wouldn't refuse to integrate, I NEVER said that. I said they wouldn't refuse to come out of their home, because eventually society requires them to come out, whether it be to seek health care or unemployment benefits. And if their husbands refuse them to get out for anything, then I believe Austria has a law agaist kidnapping.

Jesus! You really don't give a crap about those people that are forced under social control! And you have the guts to call a fourth of your own population xenophobes, what about yourself?!