great list, would say too many nintendo games up there but they are really great games though. appreciate the hard work. XC at 30. and you'll see Splatoon crack the top 50. impressive.

Do we know when this website was created? It seems odd that 2 out of 3 poster is a Nintendo fan.

This is an impressive project to gather all of the 350 games and make a list out of it. I guess this shows that Nintendo games (old and new) still resonate among most people here. Heck, Splatoon in the top 50? I guess you can say the top 20 or top 10 are typical and predictable in a way. Nevertheless, great job!

2006, but became very popular the following year.

OT: I'm glad to see TTYD in the top 25! Such an amazing game.

Yeah, no Fifa games in it. Only in an american website...

Great work Smeags!

Ocarina at #1 again, Uncharted 2 above The Last of Us. Yeah, I'm satisfied.

Now to get Knights of the Old Republic up at least 100 spots; I mean, it's not even in the top games of 2003, what's that about? And to get MediEvil in there at all. Need to start pulling my weight on these, maybe I should spam 'em everywhere this year to raise awareness or something.

I wonder how high the position of Splatoon will get in the next few years.
I'm sorry if I couldnt deliver my top 50 but I decided to wait a couple years so that I can give a top 50 that doesn't give praise to meh games only because of my young age...

I think the attention it's gotten the last couple of years with the VC release, Earthbound beginnings on VC, Mother 3 on Japan VC, have helped it reach a new audience. Also, I think Undertale might have gotten some people into it. Definitely deserve to make 50! (if not higher)

I really like this list, but of course I'm a big Nintendo fan.

Also, while not necessarily my favorite game of all time (there are few other contenders) Ocarina of Time really deserves to be on top. It is the only game that comes close to being 'consensus greatest of all time'. Like Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band is usually thought of as the greatest album of all time, Ocarina of time is usually the first game that springs to mind

Holy crap Smeags, what an effort.

Thanks for taking the time to go through this.

Amazing job! Thanks for this and the entire event!

It's amazing seeing Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door at 23. I really didn't think there were that many people who loved it as much as I did. It's pretty much perfection and my favorite game of all time.