By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Metal Gear Solid 5, The Last of Us, or Grand Theft Auto 5 which is more deserving of its 10/10 score?

 

OP

Metal Gear Solid 5 14 11.67%
 
The Last of Us 74 61.67%
 
Grand Theft Auto 5 14 11.67%
 
Show results. 17 14.17%
 
Total:119
DerNebel on 28 September 2015
Ruler said:

MGS5

take away the story in the last of us and its a mediocore game, take away the open world gameplay from gta5 and its mediocore as well. People who complain about MGS5 havent played it yet or arent undertsanding the story and gameplay mechanics

There is nothing that could qualify as "too deep" or hard to understand about MGSVs story for the average adult. It's simply not well written.



Around the Network
KingofTrolls on 28 September 2015

The answer is below.



Roronaa_chan on 28 September 2015

If you need to take something away from TLOU then inevitably you are admitting TLOU is better



Teeqoz on 28 September 2015
Ruler said:
BraLoD said:


I'm sorry, but that was one of the worst arguments I've seem in a while.
Taking away game strengths is by no means a valid point to say anything.

TLoU was built whole around a really well paced story and how the bonding between chars would make it weight more.
GTA5 was built whole around how could the world be more interesting to the player by exploring it.

What if I took away 3D gameplay from Mario 64?
What if I took away Colossi from Shadow of the Colossus?

What if I take away Kojima from MGSV?

I'm sorry, but that doesn't make any sense.

take away all conversations/cutscenes in mgs5 and the Last of Us and tell me which would be the better product?


That is an awful argument. TLoU focuses more on the story, so it'll be more impacted by taking away the story. Just tell me which game is the best when they have all they have. No point in comparing MGSV without cutscenes to TLOU without cutscenes, cause we can compare the full experience of both, including everything. That's what matters. Not how good it is when you remove important stuff, but how good it is when it has everything that it does.



LudicrousSpeed on 28 September 2015

I haven't played MGSV but neither of the other two deserve a 10 but I would give it to GTA V as far as being the closest. Shitty controls and long winded plot bring it down. LoU I'd give a 6 for the single player and a 9 for the multi (pre pay to win microtransactions). So maybe an 8 overall. The MP was damn good.

Though, I have not played GTA V since the online heists. Maybe that makes it an easy decision.



Around the Network
Eddie_Raja on 28 September 2015

Hands down The Last Of Us. "The Citizen Kane moment of gaming". Next question...



Prediction for console Lifetime sales:

Wii:100-120 million, PS3:80-110 million, 360:70-100 million

[Prediction Made 11/5/2009]

3DS: 65m, PSV: 22m, Wii U: 18-22m, PS4: 80-120m, X1: 35-55m

I gauruntee the PS5 comes out after only 5-6 years after the launch of the PS4.

[Prediction Made 6/18/2014]

Eddie_Raja on 28 September 2015
Teeqoz said:
Ruler said:

take away all conversations/cutscenes in mgs5 and the Last of Us and tell me which would be the better product?


That is an awful argument. TLoU focuses more on the story, so it'll be more impacted by taking away the story. Just tell me which game is the best when they have all they have. No point in comparing MGSV without cutscenes to TLOU without cutscenes, cause we can compare the full experience of both, including everything. That's what matters. Not how good it is when you remove important stuff, but how good it is when it has everything that it does.


Bingo, and the gameplay in TLoU was brilliant as well.  Sounds like we have another one of THESE people complaining about an amazing story that in no way hinders gameplay, and in fact enhances it.



Prediction for console Lifetime sales:

Wii:100-120 million, PS3:80-110 million, 360:70-100 million

[Prediction Made 11/5/2009]

3DS: 65m, PSV: 22m, Wii U: 18-22m, PS4: 80-120m, X1: 35-55m

I gauruntee the PS5 comes out after only 5-6 years after the launch of the PS4.

[Prediction Made 6/18/2014]

Kagerow on 28 September 2015

None of them. All three have noticeable and glaring flaws in its design compared to its competitors at the time.

I honestly think current measurement of scoring is quite broken. While many suggest to remove score entirely, I think better approach is uncapped from base 10, instead of percentile.



Miyamotoo on 28 September 2015

I did not played yet MGSV but i saw lotsa comments of players and definitely not 10/10 game, more 8.5/10 game.



DannyDesario on 28 September 2015

I can't stand the bad AI in TLOU, GTA lost my interest for a minute when the online came out broken. MGS V doesn't deserve a 10 but it's the best of the 3 IMO

TLOU
SP:6/10
MP:7/10
Overall:6.5/10

GTA V (Launch)
SP 8.5/10
MP 1/10
Launch Score: 5/10 / Current Score: 8/10

MGS V:
SP: 9/10
MP: ????
Overall: 8.0-9.5



Currently Playing: N/A

Anime and Studying is life RN