Metal Gear Solid 5, The Last of Us, or Grand Theft Auto 5 which is more deserving of its 10/10 score?

[Teeqoz]

Ruler said:

BraLoD said:

I'm sorry, but that was one of the worst arguments I've seem in a while.
Taking away game strengths is by no means a valid point to say anything.

TLoU was built whole around a really well paced story and how the bonding between chars would make it weight more.
GTA5 was built whole around how could the world be more interesting to the player by exploring it.

What if I took away 3D gameplay from Mario 64?
What if I took away Colossi from Shadow of the Colossus?

What if I take away Kojima from MGSV?

I'm sorry, but that doesn't make any sense.

take away all conversations/cutscenes in mgs5 and the Last of Us and tell me which would be the better product?

That is an awful argument. TLoU focuses more on the story, so it'll be more impacted by taking away the story. Just tell me which game is the best when they have all they have. No point in comparing MGSV without cutscenes to TLOU without cutscenes, cause we can compare the full experience of both, including everything. That's what matters. Not how good it is when you remove important stuff, but how good it is when it has everything that it does.