Yeah but now TLOU isn't in the list while it scored higher than SSBU, and it got beaten by GTA V in 2014. To be fair it released within a year of the PS3.

I can't say I can agree with that. I got all 120 stars in both Galaxy games with fair ease. I raged at a few parts as I  have mentioned before and I was PISSED on the one level to the point I refrained from smashing my Wiimote. Sunshine on the other hand gave me more troubles with more of the shines. While Galaxy had more levels in general, they felt smaller and had less areas to explore in. Some of the planets, especially in Galaxy 2 only took mere minutes to complete.

As for Bioshock.... how were any of them difficult, I damn near got all the achievements for it. I played all 3 Bioshock games and I found them to be quite simple. Honestly you can't even really die or lose your progress. If you dodge and have the right abilities and upgrades then the game becomes a breeze and gets simpler as you progress through the game. Personally I found Bioshock to be one of the simplest shooters to exist, but maybe that's just me. I do play a lot of them so perhaps that could be part of it.

I was being sarcastic with Bioshock, I love them, I think they are some of the best FPS ever done, but they are not really difficult at all.

I remember having many troubles to find all the stuff on mario galaxy (specially the 2) but I would have to play the first again to see if my memory is wrong.

I think Mario Galaxy is not a lot easier than Bioshock to be honest.

The hype for Super Smash died as fast as it started. LOL

No it's not easier than Bioshock. I kind of figured something was up with that comment but I didn't detect the sarcasm. I was personally disappointed in the difficulty of a lot of Nintendo titles in the Wii and currently the Wii U era. Game Cube and N64 games had a great deal of a challenge to them. The hardest first party title on Wii was probably Metroid Prime 3. Such a great game but damn! Casual isn't worth mentioning as it has no difficulty at all. The first mini  boss is 3 shots on casual compared to 20-30 on normal (using power shots as well). Then there is veteran which is the point where everyone shuts the eff up. Helios alone made the normal difficulty worth a mention compared to other shooters.

Then we had Echoes and F-Zero GX on the Game Cube. LOL @ F-ZERO GX!

The PS1/2 THPS really are that good. You don't even need to skate to be hooked.

So, explain The Last of Us and Uncharted 2. Journey was 2nd in number of GOTY awards in 2012.

Hardly. 

Glad you agree it was unnecessary though.

Pretty sure people are still hyped about Smash, especially with all the DLC updates.

Im sure Half-Life 2 sits on a 97 not 96 but doesn't matter. 2015 looks to be the Witcher 3 with a 93 so far.
Nintendo do make quality games. They own the review boards.