Super Smash Bros. Brawl 9
Lost Odyssey 7
Condemned 2: Bloodshot 5
Rainbow six vegas 2 7
Army of Two 4
God Of war: Chain of Olympus 7
Lost: The Videogame 3
Sins of a solar empire 8
Professor layton 7
Apollo Justice; Ace Attorney 6
Penumbra: Black Plague 6
Dark Mist 8
Sega superstars tennis 7
Space invaders extreme 8

These are harsh to all those involved, besides Brawl.

I'm just happy Brawl scored AAA with Edge, this was the harshest critic left, that mattered. 

Ouch to Layton, Apollo, and GoW.

I have Layton and Apollo, and can say for a fact, these games are tremendously fun. Dunno about God of Puzzle, but I bet its pretty good.

Sega Tennis scores a 7, that's pretty great, all things considered.

Go Brawl! 

Ouch to everyone but Brawl and Lost, those two were deserved.

is army of two really that bad game? it has an average 77.6% on gamerankings.

lol,

I love the series,but the game indeed looks horrible. 

Brawl is on track to be GotY contender so far. 

Yay, you are back!

man, pretty harsh scores all around. Apollo for 6? LO and GoW for 7? I have a feeling most of the scores deserve a 1 more.

What the hell is Dark Mist and why does it deserve more than GoW or LO?

Army of 2 got raped. *sighs*

Edit: Professor Layton got 7 too, that game is a lock for 8 at least. 

I was fair in my assessment, that many games were under-rated, including probably God of War.

Fanboys did get owned last night, though:

WOW !!... those guys ate something bad yesterday and took it out on those games ... low scores overall, well ... even though Sega tennis and space invaders had good scores at least :P

Gamespot gave it a 9.5 ???, most of the time they are pretty harsh on Wii games, great score :) 

Edge is usually harsh on most games, it has to be very special to get a 9 by them, unlike many other review site who seem to give 9s out like candy*

*never accept candy from someone giving it away for free.

GOW looks off but I'd need to read review to judge how they got to 7. Still, in a funny way its nice to see these kinds of scores - I definately felt reviews were suddenly getting too 'soft' on big titles for a while.

From demo I'm willing to bet I disagree with the GoW review though...

Apollo is a niche title. I would say to anyone who is a fan of the series already, it's a 10/10, simply because it progresses an amazing story.

However, I believe people new to the series would hate it.

Also, most review sites have 7.5 as an average. I think Edge's average is 5/10.