I like both.
Hard to even draw a line at what really is realistic and what is about color. The majority of games ever made are colorful and cartoony. Nintendo only fans pretty much have to vote cartoony.

Chinese cartoons > all.

Seriously reality is ugly, 2D world should be anything but realistic to catch my eye.

You are confusing graphics with aesthetics.

I think both have important values, but I chose "cartoony."

What I REALLY love is an anime style somewhere between the two. Games like the KH series and modern FF titles are beautiful beyond words in my eyes.

I can go with any art style. I just want to say that I'm playing Gravity Rush on Vita and that game is soooooo pretty to me right now.

I think that, as long as the developer is creative, I'm happy. I just want to be wowed.

I like both art styles. Neither one of them is superior.

I play & enjoy both, as long as they are fun & with solid gameplay.