I'm actually quite baffled by the answers here. People here saying that the Xbox wins "no contest" is straight bulls$%t! You all act as if the Xbox line up was SO much better than the PlayStation's. Both of them had lackluster lineups this year. Nothing that compelling that I would say would have either of them winning this year as far as games.
To be honest though, PlayStation has more games. That can't even be debated. More diverse line up. However, I'm aware this is a question about personal preference of whose games is better. I'm still surprised that Xbox is winning only because PS has more and there should be a game that would satisfy at least one gamer from each genre. I would have expected the PS4 to edge the Xbox out. Next year is going to be very interesting indeed.