I see your point, though it is very reasonable especially being for pokemon but the thing to remember is unlike Skylanders/Disney Infinity, this will be cross with ?? titles instead of a lock in 1 game. Here's wat i mean...

Your Scenario.... Pokemon WiiU game, only pokemon nfc toys. Pikachu+Charizard+Greninja+etc...  Though i 100% agree this would be a smash hit (just makes sense), but how about the next game(s) that comes out that uses amiibo? Can you use your Snorlax figurine? Your Mewtwo?

With the way they are going especially with SSB first, thats a game where multiple franchises are already in one, so for example after SSB releases.. We'll have Mario+Peach+Link+Samus! MK8 is confirmed with Amiibo so now your already bought Mario+Peach can be used for another game right there! Mario Party 10 (ewwww, ruined the franchise) has amiibo working with it as well.

I do support your idea, especially 2015 for 3DS would do wonders with pokemon. I just think a simply Nintendo allstar franchise is the smartest way to go to get the public's attention, but hey im just TBONE51 :P

I think you are ignoring that all Skylanders figures are compatible with 3 games (Spyro's Adenture, Giants, Swap Force), and the upcoming Trap Team.

Disney has also said that all current figures will be supported in Infinity 2.0. 

In addition, except for Pokemon, the catalog of characters that Skylands and Disney have just squash everything else.

Well just checked, your right. My bad, but still the point i was trying to make is the figurines will work with many different franchises instead of being locked into one, so it doesn't squash everything else.

If somebody wanted to play new metroid and had already bought a Samus figurine for SSB for its features... Now lets say that same figurine has data that when playing a metroid game gave you access for a new suit or gave additional power ups to the player that would be awesome.

Or maybe a Zero Suit Samus Figurine which lets you play without the suit in th game at times? Possibilities are endless.

Some people here might only collect a few just because they like the Zelda franchise or the DK one. Bringing them to multiple franchises definitely seems to be a win/win