By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Why the Wii U is the worst Nintendo console of all time (Gamecube comparison)

Einsam_Delphin said:
Err, what!? The Gamecube is absolute garbage compared to the Wii U! Vastly inferior graphics, no online play, no backwards compatibility, no multimedia features, less controller options, no eShop, no off TV play, poor design, no free game included, and so ons!


This is why context is important.  



Around the Network

You should adjust the GC launch price for inflation which is closer to $260. It doesn't change your point, but you present a better case when you don't leave things like this out. Unadjusted prices only make the information seem biased.



Richard_Feynman said:
Trunkin said:
GC's controller was far from standard. Hell, the Wii U gamepad is more standard than it was, so I don't see your complaint there.

I actually kind of agree with your other points, though. From the looks of things, Nintendo's first party output this gen actually will be less than it was for the GC, and third party support is already even more dismal than GC's as well.

I still can't understand how Ninty could launch the Gamecube at such a ridiculously low price without taking major losses. Whatever their secret was, they clearly forgot it with the Wii U - they're definitely asking for a lot of dough for what you get.

- Four face buttons CHECK

- Two analogue sticks CHECK

- DPad CHECK

- Shoulder buttons CHECK

It was not far from standard. The ONLY difference was that it had only 3 shoulder buttons versus 4 on PS2 and XBox. Just cause the buttons are shaped a little differently doesn't change the nuber of inputs and where they are located at all. 

Yes. 3 shoulder buttons as opposed to four, and weirdly placed and shaped buttons that made it impossible to do some fighting game combos. Also, non-clickable thumbsticks.

The Wii U Gaamepad, on the other hand, has four shoulder buttons, standard button placement, clickable thumbsticks, and everything else you could expect from a modern videogame controller. Literally the ONLY thing that sets it apart is the screen in the middle, which doesn't actually interfere with any of your other controls.



I've owned every single Nintendo home console except the NES and in my opinion, other then the SNES the Gamecube was by far the best Nintendo home console. I owned a PS2 and a Gamecube at the time, found myself playing my PS2 every few months and playing my Gamecube every other day at the very least. If a third party game was on both consoles, I usually bought it for the Gamecube and there were indeed a lot of them.

With that being said, it's still way to early to judge the Wii U. It hasn't found its footing yet and honestly Nintendo isn't doing a very good job helping it succeed but that could very well change. The issue is that no one wants to make games for Nintendo outside of a few developers like Ubisoft for example. Which means that if they want to succeed, they would have to speed up their production unit and start releasing first party titles at a more steady pace. Not one game every few months, one game every month at the very least.

If they can pull that off, people will jump on board and the results will show it. Maybe then they can start re-establishing their relationship with third party devs because even though I believe in the business model I just proposed, it won't keep them going for very long.



funny you say about deserved sales when gamecube was the worst sold console from nintendo



 

 

We reap what we sow

Around the Network

It's not only worst Nintendo's console but one of worst consoles ever.



Richard_Feynman said:
Trunkin said:
GC's controller was far from standard. Hell, the Wii U gamepad is more standard than it was, so I don't see your complaint there.

I actually kind of agree with your other points, though. From the looks of things, Nintendo's first party output this gen actually will be less than it was for the GC, and third party support is already even more dismal than GC's as well.

I still can't understand how Ninty could launch the Gamecube at such a ridiculously low price without taking major losses. Whatever their secret was, they clearly forgot it with the Wii U - they're definitely asking for a lot of dough for what you get.

- Four face buttons CHECK

- Two analogue sticks CHECK

- DPad CHECK

- Shoulder buttons CHECK

It was not far from standard. The ONLY difference was that it had only 3 shoulder buttons versus 4 on PS2 and XBox. Just cause the buttons are shaped a little differently doesn't change the nuber of inputs and where they are located at all. 

I think of the Gamecube controller as a semi-standard.

It had 4 face buttons, but their placement and size weren't the standard set by the SNES.

It had one analog stick and one analog camera-stick, two different shapes and not the standard.

The D-Pad was tiny and not suitable for 2D platformers or Fighters.  

The clickable analog shoulder triggers were better than the standard at the time, but the 3rd Z trigger was oddly placed.

Overall the GC controller was good but the Wii U gampad resembles more of what an industry standard controller looks & feels like (besides the big touch screen in the middle).



Uabit said:
It's not only worst Nintendo's console but one of worst consoles ever.


ps4 is worst



 

 

We reap what we sow

Uabit said:
It's not only worst Nintendo's console but one of worst consoles ever.

What about Virtual Boy, Atari Jaguar, 3DO, Atari 5200 and all those wonderful consoles?



                
       ---Member of the official Squeezol Fanclub---

Richard_Feynman said:
Einsam_Delphin said:
Err, what!? The Gamecube is absolute garbage compared to the Wii U! Vastly inferior graphics, no online play, no backwards compatibility, no multimedia features, less controller options, no eShop, no off TV play, poor design, no free game included, and so ons!


Don't know if you're serious. But if you are, then one could say the same about the NES, SNES, N64, PSOne, PS2, Dreamcast, etc.


What does me being serious or not have to do with anything? What I've said are just the facts! Hardware-wise the Wii U is greatly superior to all those consoles!