Hasquarl said: Pikmin 2 has more varied gameplay and greater things to do, but Pikmin 1 is where the atmosphere is. Basically, in Pikmin 1, you've crashed landed on a planet and have to use Pikmin to recover lost pieces of your ship to get home before your time limit is up (30 days, I think). It's very strategic and you have to be able to micromanage multiple tasks to get everything done during the day. Bosses can get very difficult. Pikmin 2 was good, but it did away with the time limit which took away from the experience. Also, while the a surface levels were fun, the dungeons sucked. However, they're both good game and I'd recommend picking them up if you can find them before playing Pikmin 3. |
This was a really interesting post because it almost exactly sums up my experience with the Pikmin series. And it's rare to see, because the general opinion seems to be that the second game is miles better.
Pikmin 1 is one of my favourite games of all time. It just has this incredible atmosphere of discovery in an alien world; but on the backdrop of being on a fixed time limit so you can repair your ship and find your way home. I really, really enjoyed it.
The second game was still an exceptionally good title, but I felt it never really recaptured that lightning-in-a-bottle that the first game did. I much preferred exploring the overworld than exploring the dungeons, so it was a big disappointment for me that so much time was spent in them. The removal of the time limit took away some of the urgency of the game too.
But anyway, @ OP, I'd personally recommend playing the first Pikmin game now before trying the new game.