Yeah, but many people might have expected more since they gave Skyward Sword a 10.

Well not every game is as Epic as Skyward Sword, lol but again, this is just one review, famisutu just gave it a 38/40, seems like this game will do fine in the reviews.

cannot wait but now i have to wait until the 2nd of december since i will buy teh mario 3d land pack (whit 3DS)

gamepro germany 92%,

somehow I think this games overall score is gonna be ok. I'll be satisfied if it gets anything above mid-high 80s on mc. I'm sick of all this crying just cos one person out of 30 marked (insert name of your current favourite game franchise here) lower than other critics. I don't care if it's game ot year material or not. I just want a good fun game (which is what it seems to be from all reports so far, yeah even edge).
Getting all dark over an 8 from edge is a major overreaction... if I was worried about a score from edge and it got over 7 I'd breath a huge sigh of relief and think it was a likely to be an exceptional game,esp given some of the games they've given that score to. It's edge, they're wankers...deal with it.

8?

/world

Famitsu gave Nintendogs a 40... Famitsu has become relaly pathetic really :P Not saying SM3D Land isn't a great game, but basing it on a famitsu review is not the way to go

the german gamepro has an interview with the famitsu guys in the newest magazine and they asked how they give these points. they said they look at how a game is for the people who like this kind of game. so they don't give the score as a score for everyone they only look at the target audience and that's why a nintendodogs got 40 poinst, they think it's perfect for people who like to play a nintedog game.

they say it's not important for the score if one part of the game is good or bad, only if the target audience will like the game. so if you like 3d mario games you will like mario 3d land. if you like pet games you will love nintendogs. and if you love ego-shooters they just don't say you how you will like nintendogs or mario 3d land.

so it's possible that there are 1000 better games than nintendogs they don't care they will still give these games only 35 points or so and nintendogs 40 points because they think that the 35 point games could be even better for people who love those games but they miss something important for this kind of game.

in the past they only had weather symbols like a sunny/cloudy/rainy pic to review a game haha.

can u give a link. and I updated the OP with famitsu quote

so basically, EDGE is harsh with their scores. Anybody know which games have gotten a 10 from EDGE, besides Skyward Sword?