The faith people put in Metacritic. So Metacritic is overrated.
The constant butthurt fanboys relating Kinect to Eye toy despite a large gap between them, if tech does not innovate in that time, then I don't know what innovation is.
Kinect is overrated , even I think that.
COD franchise, previous is as good as the last. Most of the guns commonly used in Blops are recycled from COD4.
Red Alert 3 - Major b00bage.
Motion controls in general. That ruins gaming, for me.
The people who are predicting sales in range of 5m for new IP's, just 'cos they're exclusive to their platform of choice.(Kingdoms, Agent, TLG etc)
These threads.
The proper use of Mo instead of MO
GTA IV, I went in without many expectations and was nicely let down. Cheers.
UPDATE: BluRay, to some extent graphics, sports games, colour of the controller/gaming system, turtlebeach headset, many games.