By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - Does anyone think PS3 can realistically get to second place?

Michael-5 said:
TheNoobHolocaust said:

The real question is does anyone think it won't. The majority of the people on this site believe it will surpass 360 sometime within the next year or two.



Don't impose your opinions as the feelings of everyone on the website here buddy. PS3 had 1 year where it outsold the 360, and now it outsells the 360 by roughly 30,000 unit a week. IF Sony holds this trend all year (which I don't beleive will happen with Halo, Gears and Natal), thats a 1.5 million units a year difference. With a 5 million unit difference, that would take a little over 3 years to catch up, and by then Microsoft at least wil have released a successor

My opinion is that Sony will remain in position number 3, and Microsoft will make sure of it. Microsoft can drop it's price still, where if Sony did, it would lose money on the PS3 again. The only reason PS3 sales jumped last year, and remain up are because of the PS3 Slim, and the $300 price tag. Guess what Microsoft is doing this fall?? A rumoured 360 slim, a price drop, and Natal which unlike the Move, is inovative. Gran Turismo 5 is not enough to prevent this.

I'll agree this website has a lot more PS3 fanboys then Microsoft, but this temporary lead has gotten to your heads. Yes Sony is pushing more PS3's then Microsoft is pushing 360's in Japan and now Europe, but Japans Market is tiny, and only accounts for 5 million PS3's. The NA market is the biggest, and all the big HD games target the american audience. Call of Duty, Halo, GTA, Red Dead Redemption, etc.

So realistically, no I do not think PS3's sales will ever surpass 360's sales. I would even be surprised if they reduce the difference to less then 5 million units (360's initial lead due to its one year head start)


you're so full of it. FIrst of  all ''barelly 30.000'' is a totally false statement.Go look up the lateest worldwide numbers and the numbers for the past 6 months.  Also i would like to know how can you see in the future and say sony cant drop the price. They said their goal is 13-15 million sold from march 2010 till march 2011. they know they cant achieve this with 299$ price. You say ''their gonna start losing money again'',but how about these new 40mm chips or whatever they're called that will reduce the mahfacturing costs??? Or that Sony is preparing new PSN premium serviece that will earn even more money than original PSN? You might also wanna know, that every system gets most of its sales when its 199$. PS3 is the only console that didnt reach that price yet.

 

Then you start talking about a rumoured 360, (yes that means its a rumor, just like MGS4 on xbox 360) a price drop that none of us knows if its really gonna happen. And i dont wanna start any debate, but Move AND NAtal are NOT inovative.both ideas have been done before

And in case you didnt know Europe & Japan >>>>> America.So PS3 doesnt have to take over America from xbox 360.

 

And PS3 and xbox 360 gap is ALREADY smaller than 5 million ( PS3-xbox 360 launch was 5.4 million, not 5.0 million btw)



Around the Network
Michael-5 said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Smashed said:
Darth Tigris said:
I really don't think hardly anyone on this site really understand the potential of holiday 2010 for the 360. Many here have forgotten the situation in 2008 when the PS3 was only 6 million away and had a ton of momentum because of a 2007 price cut and huge marketing push. Then came September, the 360 dropped from $279 to $199 for the Arcade SKU and, before you knew, the lead was back up to 8 million.

You see that, folks. The 360 lead was down to around about 5 million and some 8 months later it was back up to 8 million.

Do you hear me? Ok, let me slow it down for you.

Sept 08 - May 09 - 360 lead went from 6 mil to 8.4 mil (360 price cut)
Sept 09 - May 10 - 360 lead went from 8 mil to 5 mil (PS3 price cut)

Its a pattern that repeats and we're on the PS3 growth cycle this time. Come this fall we WILL have Halo Reach, Fable III and 'Project Natal'. We may also have a Slim and a price cut. So what will that likely mean for the game industry? See pattern above. Rinse and repeat.

For the PS3 to truly secure 2nd place, we'd have to see something DRASTICALLY different than the pattern that has already been established this gen.

You completely IGNORED the games coming out for PS3 this year, didn't you?

You want to talk moving consoles? Talk Gran Turismo 5.

As if Halo Reach will sell MONSTER consoles, right on there bud. Most people who are getting Reach already owned a 360 to begin with, it will only get it's boost off bundles. Fable III will move some consoles, how much do you think a Fable game is really going to move, is the game going to be ground breaking?

You completely also ignored one of Sony's biggest things this year, Move.

Or did you just forget them?


living in the past are we Darth Tigris? current trends will decide this race. im sure sony will only counter a price drop. although it may not be wise. hey everybody. it's time to play chess. the board is the 2010 holiday season. heres my take on it.

holiday season console sells

PS3 10m

360 7m

 

 


In 2009, when Sony's price cut/PS3 Slim happened Microsoft also had a price cut, and a selection of great titles too. Halo 3: ODST, Left 4 Dead 2, a 360 favoured Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, Mass Effect 2 (I know it came out in January), Forza Motorsport 3, and Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City. Still it's sales suffered. Sony just had more, the PS3 Slim, Uncharted 2, FF XIII in Japan, and a PS3 favoured FIFA and PES. The key factor, the PS3 Slim.

In 2008, when Microsoft had a significant sale gain, Sony had some great fall titles too. Resistance 2, LittleBig Planet, a PS3 favoured PES, and FIFA, and Motorstorm: Pacific Rift. However Microsoft had a lot more, Gears of War 2, Left 4 Dead, a 360 favoured Call of duty: World at War, and Fallout 3, and Fable 2.

Sales fluctuate! Darth Tigris is making a very valid and logical point. This Fall Microsoft will not only sell more 360's then Sony will sell PS3's, but I think it will increase it's lead back to 8 million by next fall.

Yes PS3 has Move, but listen to Michael Pachner. It's probably going to sell 1:5 as many units compared to Microsofts Natal. Also Microsoft will most likely price the Natal under $100 to compete with the Move. Gamewise, Microsoft has more, but Sony had an amazing spring. Sony has Gran Turismo 5, and hopefully the Last Guardian too. Microsoft has Halo: Reach, Fable 3, and probably a Left 4 Dead 3 (lol!). However the key factor is Natal, and a 360 Slim. Thats what ushed Sony ahead last year, I don't understand how it won't push 360 up this year.

Comparing Halo and Gran Turismo as console pushers, is just fanboyism. So I'm just going to name some key factors. Both franchises sell games always getting 9.5/10 or higher. There already is a Halo 3 on 360, so it's a valid arguement to think it won't push too many newcomers to the 360 since they came by in 2007. However, there was also a GT5 Prologue.

Another valid arguement is stating the sales factor with respect to the amount of consoles sold. Halo 2 sold 8 million units on a system with only 24 million sold. Thats 1/3. GT4 was the best selling GT game which sold 15 million units on a system with 140 million units. Thats a little over 1/10. Halo 3 sold 11/40 which is 1/4, still good. So following this logic, GT5 may only sell 4-6 million units. Thats not that much more then Forza Motorsport 3, so is this a big deal? We will see later in the year.

So logically, 360 will outsell the PS3 this fall for the same reasons 360 outsold the PS3 in 2007, 2008, and for the same reasons PS3 outsold the 360 in 2009. The real question is, will it continue to outsell 360's over PS3's in 2011? Depends if Natal takes off,if Natal is as popular as the Wii....well then Sony will never catch up.

I lovethe PS3, 360, Wii, DS, and PSP (not PC :(), and I am just looking at this reasonably.

P.S. MarcusDJackson, current trends change, until last August the 360 was consistantly outselling the PS3. That changed right?

The only continuous trend is that, the console with the better games/upgrades will lead the holiday in terms of sales. 360 Slim plus Natal beat the PS3 Move, and arguably Halo, Gears, L4D3, Fable 3, and a 360 favoured CoD are better then GT5, The Last Guardian, and a PS3 favoured PES, and FIFA. 2006-2008 that was, technically Wii, but in this arguement 360, and 2009 was PS3. One PS3 won fall battle does not win the console war


not listening to  Michael Pachner sounds better. i kow one PS3 fall battle doesn't win the war. nintendo has that on lock. and you made alot of sence, but i just don't see something that happend two yr's ago as being a argument.

if thats the case then i can only assume that because the PS2 won the sixth gen PS3 will win the seventh. there are to many unnones and everything being said is based on speculation. lets not use logic cause i can say because PS3 out sold 360 last yr then it's only logical that it would do it again this yr. 



I think it is certainly possible that the PS3 can come in 2nd, and I think this holiday (and therefore E3 reveals) will be the main determiniation.

I think if Microsoft announces a slim and price cut for this year, the 360 will stay ahead until their next console releases.

I think if they announce the slim and price cut, and Natal really takes off then they will probably stay permanently.

If Microsoft is not aggressive this holiday and makes up for some of the gap PS3 has eaten up since the slim, the PS3 will catch the 360 before Microsoft's next console release.

Some people seem to expet PS3 to sell almost as well as PS2 did after PS3 released. I don't think that will happen, but I do think it will do much better than the GC or Xbox did after their their succesors launched.



This thread is going to be gold for quoting from September onwards, way too many deluded individuals with some perveted sense of loyalty for organisations that couldn't care less about them, now they have their money.  Don't bother quoting this post, there is no debate to be had in this thread.



slowmo said:

This thread is going to be gold for quoting from September onwards, way too many deluded individuals with some perveted sense of loyalty for organisations that couldn't care less about them, now they have their money.  Don't bother quoting this post, there is no debate to be had in this thread.


srry i had to because your right.



Around the Network

Which statement do you want a reference for? I made many statements.

COD has definatly contributed to console sales in at least North America in the same way PES, and FIFA sales boast console sales in Europe and Asia.  Especially Call of Duty 2, that example alone (old as it may be), completly falsifies your statement. Call of Duty is largly popular in North America, where the 360 dominate the PS3 1.75 to 1. Of course it's going to boast 360 sales.

Halo: Reach is going to be the 4th Halo on the 360, but also the biggest, and if you count Halo Wars as a Halo game, even thought it's only a FPS, you have to count GT5 Prologue because that's all Sony gamers have had to live on while waiting on GT5.

As for which brand is bigger, that's arguable. Gran Turismo has sold most of it's games over the 10 million sales mark, however, it sold over 10 million games on system with over 100 million units. PS3 is not selling anywhere nearly as well as PS1 and PS2 did, what makes you think it will sell that spectacularly? Halo on the other hand has sold, 5 and 8 million units on a system with only 24 million sales, and 11 million units on a system with 40 million sales. In my opinion, Halo: Reach will sell 11-15 million units in the long run, more then any other Halo game because this Halo will be sold onto a console with more sales then ever before. Under the same logic, I beleive GT5 will sell 6-8 milion units total, everyone that bought Prologue, some new PS3 owners, and the few people who didn't buy GT5: Prologue in anticipation of GT5.

And GT:5 Prologue is no a DEMO, it's more like a large scale BETA.

As for Michael Patchner being wrong 75% of the time, can you veryfy this reference? To my accounts his predictions are very accurate, otherwise webush would have fired him. I only know about his Wii HD prediction being wrong, and he underpredicted Boarderlands.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

the arguement is can PS3 take second place. and the answer is yes it can, but on that same note it just may not be able to.



Tiko7523 said:

so now I see the ps3 only 5 million less WORLD WIDE....(caught up big time and remember they released a year later)

 

I see that the ps3 is winning in japan and winning in europe in console sales

 

With the PS3 supplies coming better on with them having a major E3 it seems ( MS is coming hard as well)

 

does anyone really think the PS3 will be no.2 this generation? 

Ok first I want to say that the Wii just outsold PS3 in Japan recently. Second, yes I do believe PS3 will become second. Not this year. Some time around 2011-2012. Maybe even later. 5 mil is a big gap.



NINTENDO

nintendo forever . . .

I'm so full of it? Please don't be insulting, I am making a very logical and valid arguement.

I never said "Barely 30,000", I said roughly 30,000 a week. Don't put words into my mouth, there is a difference. I have been keeping track of PS3 vs 360 sales on a weekly basis since at least August 2009. Since January I have noticed the PS3 has been leading in sales over the 360 between 20,000 to 50,000 units a week. Depending heavily on game releases.

To the end of May, PS3 has sold 4 million units worldwide, 360 has sold 3 million units worldwide (according to VGChartz YTD's, as of now). That is a period of 5 months to account for a 1 million sales difference. Thats 22 weeks roughly, and 1 million divided by 22 is 45,000. More then 30,000, however you have to account the strong Spring lineup PS3 had over the 360, specifically God of War 3. Okay 30,000 is a bit off, 40,000 is a more reasonable estimate, but I did say roughly, and I in all honesty feel that this difference will diminish during fall 2010.

On Gametrailers (and I think in a news article somewhere on GT, but also from Michael Patchner), Michael Patchner stated that the new model PS3's give Sony a $30 profit at the $300 price margin. Thats 10%, which is small, Nintendo is probably making over $100 per console, and 360 is somewhere inbetween. Microsoft can afford another price drop, and still make profit on each system sold. It may only be $5 profit, or 1 penny, but still. If Sony made a price cut, they would lose money per console, just as they have been doing almost during the entire PS3 lifetime.

As for Sony's Prenium PSN service, Microsoft is also likely to release a Platnium service pack for XBL, and how is this relevant to a consoles sales??

Also, Every system gets most of it's sales at the $199 price point. Oh man, SHOW ME WHERE YOU FOUND THIS OUT!! Michael Patchner stated that Microsoft sells about 80% of it's units at the medium range price point ($299), and that only about 10% buy the $199 arcade model, and 10% buyt the $399 Elite model. If most consoles get their sales at the $199 point, then this shouldn't be happening! However it is, so...your statement is false.

I'm not trying to insilt you, but you seem to be making up your arguements. PS3 is a great console, I have one, and a 360. I just don't think the PS3 will become number 2 in sales. I beleive this because Microsoft is a corperate demon. They will not allow PS3's console to outsell the 360, even if it means giving away 360 consoles. Microsoft has the money to do this, and it is crutial for their system to remain in position number 2 to keep up their reputation for the next generation of consoles.

MGS4 on 360 was a rumor created in forums, a 360 Slim is a media originated rumor, and unlike the MGS4-360 rumor, it has evidence to back it up. Please don't compare the two, as they have a completly different background. You can however compare the 360 Slim rumour to the FFXIII and FFXIII Versus being multi console rumors as those were originated in the media, and hang on...FFXIII is on 360 too right??

Microsoft will definatly do some sort of price cut, and Natal package. Like I said they are a corporate demon. They will do anything to stay ontop, and they have room for a price cut. I feel they will, after all they are trying to attract Wii gamers to the Natal.

As for Japan/Europe >>>> Americas, first of all 23 million/40 million 360's are sold in Americas, so for 360, that is not the case. Also in many European, and asian countries, 360 outsells the PS3. Countries like Britain and Korea (On VgChartz, just compare hardware total and look on the right). Now in Japan, PS3 has sold 5.2 million units, and 360 has sold 1.3 million, where DS is over 30 million. Japan is a dominatly handheld market, it doesn't really affect PS3/360 sales much.

So for PS3, Europe > Americas > Japan, but for 360 Americas > Europe and Japan combined. The important thing is total sales, not just regional. In europe, both consoles have sold roughly the same number of total units, and if Microsoft blows everyone away this fall (which I think they will), that could change.

Another point PS3/360 regional totals - Japan is 6.5 million, Europe is 31.5 million, Americas is 37.2 million. Europe Japan is 38 million, just above the americas total. I think Microsoft holding American popularity, especially at a ratio of 1.75 to 1 is a very important factor. With the Natal, price cut, and selection of great games comming out, I think Microsoft will pull itself out of this slump.

It may not, but I have given numerous valid arguements supporting my claim, your just bashing me because my points oppose your feelings.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Michael-5 said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Smashed said:
Darth Tigris said:
I really don't think hardly anyone on this site really understand the potential of holiday 2010 for the 360. Many here have forgotten the situation in 2008 when the PS3 was only 6 million away and had a ton of momentum because of a 2007 price cut and huge marketing push. Then came September, the 360 dropped from $279 to $199 for the Arcade SKU and, before you knew, the lead was back up to 8 million.

You see that, folks. The 360 lead was down to around about 5 million and some 8 months later it was back up to 8 million.

Do you hear me? Ok, let me slow it down for you.

Sept 08 - May 09 - 360 lead went from 6 mil to 8.4 mil (360 price cut)
Sept 09 - May 10 - 360 lead went from 8 mil to 5 mil (PS3 price cut)

Its a pattern that repeats and we're on the PS3 growth cycle this time. Come this fall we WILL have Halo Reach, Fable III and 'Project Natal'. We may also have a Slim and a price cut. So what will that likely mean for the game industry? See pattern above. Rinse and repeat.

For the PS3 to truly secure 2nd place, we'd have to see something DRASTICALLY different than the pattern that has already been established this gen.

You completely IGNORED the games coming out for PS3 this year, didn't you?

You want to talk moving consoles? Talk Gran Turismo 5.

As if Halo Reach will sell MONSTER consoles, right on there bud. Most people who are getting Reach already owned a 360 to begin with, it will only get it's boost off bundles. Fable III will move some consoles, how much do you think a Fable game is really going to move, is the game going to be ground breaking?

You completely also ignored one of Sony's biggest things this year, Move.

Or did you just forget them?


living in the past are we Darth Tigris? current trends will decide this race. im sure sony will only counter a price drop. although it may not be wise. hey everybody. it's time to play chess. the board is the 2010 holiday season. heres my take on it.

holiday season console sells

PS3 10m

360 7m

 

 


In 2009, when Sony's price cut/PS3 Slim happened Microsoft also had a price cut, and a selection of great titles too. Halo 3: ODST, Left 4 Dead 2, a 360 favoured Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2, Mass Effect 2 (I know it came out in January), Forza Motorsport 3, and Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Liberty City. Still it's sales suffered. Sony just had more, the PS3 Slim, Uncharted 2, FF XIII in Japan, and a PS3 favoured FIFA and PES. The key factor, the PS3 Slim.

In 2008, when Microsoft had a significant sale gain, Sony had some great fall titles too. Resistance 2, LittleBig Planet, a PS3 favoured PES, and FIFA, and Motorstorm: Pacific Rift. However Microsoft had a lot more, Gears of War 2, Left 4 Dead, a 360 favoured Call of duty: World at War, and Fallout 3, and Fable 2.

Sales fluctuate! Darth Tigris is making a very valid and logical point. This Fall Microsoft will not only sell more 360's then Sony will sell PS3's, but I think it will increase it's lead back to 8 million by next fall.

Yes PS3 has Move, but listen to Michael Pachner. It's probably going to sell 1:5 as many units compared to Microsofts Natal. Also Microsoft will most likely price the Natal under $100 to compete with the Move. Gamewise, Microsoft has more, but Sony had an amazing spring. Sony has Gran Turismo 5, and hopefully the Last Guardian too. Microsoft has Halo: Reach, Fable 3, and probably a Left 4 Dead 3 (lol!). However the key factor is Natal, and a 360 Slim. Thats what ushed Sony ahead last year, I don't understand how it won't push 360 up this year.

Comparing Halo and Gran Turismo as console pushers, is just fanboyism. So I'm just going to name some key factors. Both franchises sell games always getting 9.5/10 or higher. There already is a Halo 3 on 360, so it's a valid arguement to think it won't push too many newcomers to the 360 since they came by in 2007. However, there was also a GT5 Prologue.

Another valid arguement is stating the sales factor with respect to the amount of consoles sold. Halo 2 sold 8 million units on a system with only 24 million sold. Thats 1/3. GT4 was the best selling GT game which sold 15 million units on a system with 140 million units. Thats a little over 1/10. Halo 3 sold 11/40 which is 1/4, still good. So following this logic, GT5 may only sell 4-6 million units. Thats not that much more then Forza Motorsport 3, so is this a big deal? We will see later in the year.

So logically, 360 will outsell the PS3 this fall for the same reasons 360 outsold the PS3 in 2007, 2008, and for the same reasons PS3 outsold the 360 in 2009. The real question is, will it continue to outsell 360's over PS3's in 2011? Depends if Natal takes off,if Natal is as popular as the Wii....well then Sony will never catch up.

I lovethe PS3, 360, Wii, DS, and PSP (not PC :(), and I am just looking at this reasonably.

P.S. MarcusDJackson, current trends change, until last August the 360 was consistantly outselling the PS3. That changed right?

The only continuous trend is that, the console with the better games/upgrades will lead the holiday in terms of sales. 360 Slim plus Natal beat the PS3 Move, and arguably Halo, Gears, L4D3, Fable 3, and a 360 favoured CoD are better then GT5, The Last Guardian, and a PS3 favoured PES, and FIFA. 2006-2008 that was, technically Wii, but in this arguement 360, and 2009 was PS3. One PS3 won fall battle does not win the console war


not listening to  Michael Pachner sounds better. i kow one PS3 fall battle doesn't win the war. nintendo has that on lock. and you made alot of sence, but i just don't see something that happend two yr's ago as being a argument.

if thats the case then i can only assume that because the PS2 won the sixth gen PS3 will win the seventh. there are to many unnones and everything being said is based on speculation. lets not use logic cause i can say because PS3 out sold 360 last yr then it's only logical that it would do it again this yr. 

That's not logical. You can't just say because PS3 outsold the 360 last year, that it will do it again. Logic is baised on facts. Why did PS3 all of a sudden become more popular in 2009? What are the factors? Why was Microsoft more popular in 2007, and 2008? What are the factors? Then match these factors to 2010. Well 360 is releasing Natal, and PS3 is releasing the Move. Baised on many analyst preditctions, this will push 360 sales, but how much? Games, and a price cut also help, and those factors existed in 2007-2009. 3 years ago is not a long time ago.

In the end, I am just making speculations. I am not trying to make you guys agree with me, I am just making a valid arguement, which everyone should take into consideration. It's rude just saying one console will do better, without any evidence to back up that claim.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results