I've not read all this thread as I've neither the time nor patience. All I'll add is that the adverts here impact my enjoyment of the site, and often force me out, sometimes for a few weeks at a go.
In general, I have no issues with adverts as long as they do not interrupt my use of a site. Indeed, sometimes they can even be informative or useful, and I click through if applicable to me (so, not white teeth adverts, or weight loss adverts, but maybe for one telling me of a limited edition Mass Effect 2 digital sale). What I hate is adverts that block content; adverts that pop up, limiting my browser space; adverts that make noises without my input (I HATE this with a passion); or adverts that in anyway demand that I must interact with them to continue use of the site. I've had, and still have, all of the above issues with adverts here. To me, as a user of a site, this is intolerable, no matter how much I may enjoy the site itself.
Most recently, just two days ago, I clicked through to a topic on the forum and was presented with a full-page advert that I had to click through to read the page I requested. This was from a page which already had a pop-up at the bottom of the screen that had got in the way of the topic I wanted to click on. I left the site instead, quite annoyed with the saturation of adverts.
For me, such adverts are a big issue. I used to run a stickied thread here about Metacritic, but the adverts became such an issue for me that I did not want to visit the site. Initially, I slowed my updates to once a month from once a week, then I eventually gave up the thread altogether, even though many asked me to return. In short, the adverts drove me away as they were so intrusive, meaning the forums had one less informative thread (not much of a loss, I suppose, but I received enough emails to know that it was a loss to some).
Might I suggest that ad-blockers are not the problem here, if, indeed, anyone believes they actually are. The problem is the ads themselves, and how they are integrated into the site, and how they make people react. Blaming the casual browser for not liking how content is presented, and attempting to filter the content as it does not meet with their requirements, speaks volumes to me, and saddens me. As I mentioned already, I have no problems with ads, I have problems with intrusive ads.
That said, will I return here? Almost certainly, assuming things remain as they currently are. I like the site. I keep my complaints to myself on the most part as I've no desire to cause any issues. However, if the intrusive adverts get worse, or I just get too many one day, I will leave permanently at some point. But the loss of just one chap is hardly much of a loss to a large site such as this...














