First of all: thanks mZuzek for organizing the event, it is one of the highlights on this site in my opinion.
More to the details:
One Must Fall: 2097 made the list! It sadly didn't made my list this year (only 50 titles is REALLY limiting), but I am happy to see it is still represented. Thank you whoever put it in their list.
I am apparently the only one voting for Battle for Wesnoth, it seems not enough people played it. It is free guys!
Gylt is a little indie gem, that kinda dies with the Stadia exclusivity. It is totally worth it. You can buy it separately, without a Stadia subscription.
Beyond Good & Evil is a great game, again didn't made it in my list of 50, but @Veknoid_Outcast represented it, thank you very much.
King's Bounty II is again a game only I voted for. I hope more people will pick it up in the future. As I learned, it's history is connected to 3DO and Heroes of Might and Magic, which explains why I like it. There are definitive similarities to the Heroes series, but also with only one hero it allows for a much more focused story. I should play older entries in the King's Bounty series, this was the first time I got aware of it.
Radiant Historia is a game I already have but resides still in my backlog. I totally need to play that to form a proper opinion.
Phoenix Point was apparently only voted by me. For everyone enjoying X-COM, that is the game from the guy who invented X-COM initially in the 90s.
Rhythm Heaven Fever (which is to me as a european known as Beat the Beat: Rhythm Paradise) is a game I liked on the Wii, but again, only 50 spots isn't enough. Thanks for @green_sky for including it.
Romance of the three Kingdoms has too many games. I played XIV as the first game in the series this year, and it instantly made my list. But I see the series represented with four different games, only one of which got two votes.
People start to see the light on some of my favorite games though, there was a second vote each for Star Wars: Dark Forces, Pandora's Tower and Heroes of Might and Magic III. Thank you all for playing and liking games that are not that mainstream, but also totally worth it. Child of Light got even four votes, a total gem of a game.
I on the other hand played A Short Hike for the first time and totally loved it and I am now the second one voting for it. Same with Spiritfarer, which deserves more than two votes.
After that we get into the area of more mainstream games, which probably everyone knows anyways.
Maybe we should each pick a game that only one of us had in it's list, and play it this year. Because it probably is a worthy game making one of the exclusive 50 spots in a list, but not well known enough. For me that might be Radiant Historia, or maybe Wizardry 8. Or Alpha Centauri, also a game I wanted to try for some time. Not sure yet, but at least one of these I should play over the course of the year.