Only 3D Mario i haven't finished, easily the worst 3D Mario.

Same answer as to the question: Would I like enslaving all of mankind and being their unquestioned and eternal overlord that they will worship and love for ever and ever? YES, absolutely yes!

Though I can't remember on which platform I played that game (Game Cube? Wii?) I just remember enjoying that game. Ah the days when I was a Nintendo lover.

It was okay.... I actually think its abit underrated (alot of people almost hate it).

That said its not nearly as good a game as Mario 64, or Galaxy I + II was at there time.
In that sense its one of the more dissapointing 3D mario games.

I tried to like it, I really did, but for me it just didn't deliver the creativity and epicness that a 3D Mario should.

The unchanging tropical theme got monotonous, the music was unpleasant, and a lot of the gameplay just didn't feel fun or satisfying the way the series should. (And nearly always does) Like others here, I feel it's weakest 3D Mario to date.

I'll give it one thing though, the water effect for the ocean was and still is utterly gorgeous.

I enjoyed it very much. It’s a underrated gem, I was blown away at the graphics of the time

I liked it alright, but I'll probably never replay it.  It's decent but not great.  

The 3D Mario game I really hate is Super Mario 64.  I tried to like that game on two different platforms and I just couldn't do it.  Mario 64 really sucks.  Odyssey is really overrated too.  I probably like 3D World the best with Galaxy 1 being a close second.  3D platformers are not really my genre though.  Even the best ones are never going to make my "top games of all time list."

When I think of the game it makes me think of the gangstas from Paper Mario TTYD, which makes me happy, so yes.

I never played it. It is criminally overdue for a remake.

Yes.

Quite a lot.

I found repeating collecting moons to be really boring. There needs to be a bigger focus for a platformer imo