I think the game looked amazing, definitely one of the highlights of Sony's amazing E3 conference.

Craziest part was the best footage was finally revealed post E3. Just when you think Naughty Dog couldnt top themselves.

My issue about making such a bold statement is that playing is the proof. Looking at the extended E3 demo, I do have to say the game looks great but then again so did U3. Playing U3 I became bored half way through and took me almost a year to finish the game. For me, U2 looked great and also played great. U3 had great set piece type of gameplay but it become boring. With that said I am hoping U4 is more U2 then 3.

Liked UC3 but I was nowhere near as hyped at the reveals for UC2 or UC4.

Oh boy, oh boy, i can't wait to compare the preorder numbers!

it does certainly look fantastic, i think its safe to bet it will live up to the footage so far.
and Uncharted 2 single player > uncharted 3. U3 mulitplayer > U2.
both were amazing, and uncharted 3 had the better set pieces, but the pacing wasnt as good, and the story didnt always mesh. but gameplay, although awesome on both games, was much improved in 3. which lead to massive improvement to the already great multiplayer, to make u3 multiplayer the best

Haven't played it yet. Too early to tell.

This. 

I thought OP would be joking before i opened the thread and then i saw who it was. If a youtube clip is enough to top the benchmark game in the series. Then you really don't have much respect for the original. 

Easily. I can't believe how much new hardware has changed a 'linear' game. 

They've done so much more I'm super impressed.

I doubt UC4 can pull out a better intro sequence that what UC2 did, though.