This deserves a whole new thread XD

Reviews {Included in Meta as of 18th June 12PM GMT+2}:
39 Perfect Scores out of 88 reviews

________________________________

Eurogamer Sweden: 10/10
Joystiq: 10/10
PushSquare: 10/10
TheSixthAxis: 10/10
Telegraph: 10/10
PS Lifestyle: 10/10
Guardian: 10/10
Gameblog(fr): 10/10
Eurogamer Spain: 10/10
SpazioGames: 10/10
GameReactor Sweden: 10/10
GamesRadar: 10/10
CheatCodeCentral: 10/10
OPM UK: 10/10
VideoGamer: 10/10
Edge: 10/10
Eurogamer EU: 10/10
IGN: 10/10
Destructoid: 10/10
Giant Bomb: 10/10
The Digital Fix: 10/10
Machinima: 10/10
Digital Spy: 10/10
Everyeye.it: 10/10
Eurogamer Portugal: 10/10
Post Arcade: 10/10
Eurogamer Italy: 10/10
Games.cz: 10/10
GameOver.gr: 10/10
Eurogamer Germany: 10/10
GamingAge: 10/10
DarkZero: 10/10
GameRevolution: 10/10
LevelUp: 10/10
Game Over Online: 10/10
Impulsegamer: 10/10
DarkStation: 10/10
D+PAD Magazine: 10/10
GamerStyle: 10/10

GameTrailers: 9.8/10
NZGamer: 9.8/10
PSX Extreme: 9.8/10
Vandal Online: 9.8/10
LazyGamer: 9.8/10
3DJuegos: 9.7/10
Meristation: 9.7/10
Multiplayer.it: 9.7/10
Canadian Online Gamers: 9.7/10
DigitalChumps: 9.6/10
AUSGamer: 9.5/10
InsideGamer.nl: 9.5/10
Gamer.nl: 9.5/10
GamingTrend: 9.5/10
PSX-sense.nl: 9.5/10
LaPS3: 9.5/10
JeuxActu: 9.5/10
EGM: 9.5/10
GameInformer: 9.5/10
PS Universe: 9.5/10
Pelit (Finland): 9.5/10
ZTGD: 9.5/10
GamePlanet: 9.5/10
StrategyInformer: 9.5/10
GamesMasterUK: 9.5/10

PlayUK: 9.4/10
WorthPlaying: 9.3/10
4Players.de: 9.2/10

XGN: 9/10
The Escapist: 9/10
Metro GameCentral: 9/10
IGN Italy: 9/10
The Globe and Mail: 9/10
Games(TM): 9/10
GamesBeat: 9/10
GameReactor Denmark: 9/10
GamingNexus: 9/10
AtomicGamer: 9/10
GRYOnline.pl: 9/10
Hardcore Gamer Magazine: 9/10
Gamer.no: 9/10

NowGamer: 8.5/10

Gamespot: 8/10
Toronto Sun: 8/10
GameFront: 8/10
GameCritics: 8/10

Riot Pixels: 7.8/10
Polygon: 7.5/10

QuarterToThree: 6.0/10
________________________________

Reviews that are not included in meta (might be added later or not, I have no idea):
46 Perfect Scores out of 49 reviews

________________________________

JVM: 20/20
CVG: 10/10
Ibtimes: 10/10
Gamingbolt 10/10
Speciogames 10/10
PS-Nation 10/10
Techdigest 5/5
TheMirror 5/5
AdamSessler 5/5
Godisageek 10/10
GameReactor Norway: 10/10
GameReactor Italia: 10/10
GameReactor Spain: 10/10
Rev3 - 5/5
Empire Online - 5/5
Examiner - 5/5
Mirror - 5/5
IGN Denmark - 10/10
Financial Post - 10/10
Playstadium - 10/10
Jeuxvideomagazine - 20/20
Eurogamer Denmark - 10/10
Nextgengamingblog - 10/10
Minhembio - 10/10
JAGS - 10/10
USA Today - 4/4
3newz - 5/5
Eurogamer France - 10/10
Eurogamer Czech Republic - 10/10
Tiscali.cz - 10/10
Dailymail - 5/5
nbcnews - 10/10
The Slanted - 10/10
SFX - 5/5
Gamesector - 10/10
AnaitGames - 10/10
Videogame.it - 5/5
Accelerated-ideas - 5/5
Stuff.tv - 5/5
PSmania - 10/10
HREJ - 10/10
Boothammer - 10/10
JeuxVideo.fr - 10/10
BagoGames - 5/5
JV.Com: 19/20
Gamekult: 9+ <- (Site has never given a 10, very few game gets a 9)
Gamrreview: 9.8/10 <- (Site has never given a 9.8 previous to TLOU)
________________________________
Total perfect scores out of total reviews:
85 Perfect out of 137 Total!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Why are some of these scores not included in the metacritic?

Good job Naughty Dog on making another masterpiece.

Meta has a selection of publications it chooses to add. Most of these do not qualify. Not sure exactly how they choose but theres a list. Just google "Metacritic Game Publications" and then start looking at the sites. Would be awesome if we knew if any of those 47 perfect scores will get added xD

It doesnt really deserve a new thread at all. You already have one review thread, whats the point in having 2?

Answer it.

Whats the point?

Now the only question is, "what is the game of the generation"?
TLoU or Uncharted 2? :D both by ND

That's great.

Now we have to ask: does this stand up to the greatest games of all time? Is it genre revolutionising? I'm of the opinion that a game that just exemplifies the formula shouldn't get a 10.

That's......a lot lol

Can't wait to play it. Although I'm always a bit worried when a game scores this highly. I usually end completely disagreeing, and find those titles overrated. BioShock and GTAIV come to mind.

But hey, it's Naughty Dog, so hopefully it's every bit as good as reviewers say

Because it should attract folkes that aren't checking the review thread for potential spoilers to see the numbers

Im sure there are those out there!

New Game Network (no idea who are they) gave it 83, included in gamerankings.com
I read the conclusion and I saw some lack of consitency.