mortono said:
theprof00 said:
Sempuukyaku said: In my eyes, IGN Wii takes some serious credibility hits if they dock the game because it doesn't have a feature they want. That's just blatant lobbyism instead of serious game critique. |
It's not really a "feature they want" rather than a "industry-standard feature"
It's like COD:reflex not having mic support.
|
Online is not standard yet. There are tons of games without online gameplay that have no critisism like this (Bioshock, Super Mario Galaxy, Fallout 3, Rock Band, Wii Sports Resort, etc.) And frankly, those games don't need online. It makes me happy that they focused on single-player or local multiplayer instead of taking dev time to get the game on a network.
Craig Harris is probably one of those critics that is dissapointed with Nintendo's offering of online games, and so he rubs this into his review. He has this impression that Nintendo skimped on online (as well as having two identical toads w/ different colors) so they could bring this game before Christmas. He may be right. Without this game the Wii would be in a real bind at the end of the year.
Still, I think Nintendo decided from the start that it wouldn't be worth it to take the 4-5 extra months of dev time to build this game into a network when only 35% of the Wii user base is connected to the internet and only 4 million of those have Wii Speak (which would be required for a game like this).
|
Online is not standard yet, but in this point in time, if you are releasing a game where you introduce the game's main selling point as being multiplayer, then you better have some kind of online component.
None of those games, except rock band, make that kind of claim. But then again, rock band is consistently rated less than it could have been.
I just don't see the logic here. If the game had online mp, would you consider it a strength or a weakness? If you are indifferent to it, then good luck never getting online MP, because you guys are making it plainly obvious that you don't care for it. But then again, other things that nintendo fans have defended are weakpoints that even Nintendo has admitted. Thin lineups, lack of peripheral integration etc etc. So, I am going to keep thinking that online MP would have been good for the title, and Nintendo will eventually come out and say something like "we will consider doing online MP in the future", like they always do with [fill in the blank].
I wasn't trying to be harsh, but I'm sure it comes off this way. Either way, I still don't own a wii, and wouldn't buy one just for this game. I am just giving my opinion of what I think a 10/10 game would include. Needless to say, a 9.2 is still a very good score.