9.9


Pros:

- Great soundtrack
- Beautifully detailed worlds
- A very lengthy game for a platformer
- Playable Luigi
- Clever gameplay mechanics


Cons:

-Camera

@ultima

its BRILLIANT, but not perfect unlike MGs4!

9.8

+ great level design
+ game play
+Fun

- camera
- to easy

10/10 simply fabulous :)

9.9

Perfect... except the swimming levels are kind of clunky.

9.9

I don't really need to put much because everybody knows about this game. It's nearly perfect. What keeps it from getting the .1? Yoshi! Super Mario Galaxy 2 will be the best game ever made.

OH. Lets see what VGCHartz thinks about the whole Mario vs Metal Gear

- VGCHartz Review -

Super Mario Galaxy - 9.6

Metal Gear Solid 4 - 9.5

Mario Wins :)

{sigh}

Kyliedog gives it the lowest score.....how shocking!

9.5 only reason NO YOSHI

9.9, my favorite game since Zelda OoT on N64, before this game I wasn't a fan of 3D Mario games, but this one was just amazing, capturing the feel of the old 2D games, while also having the fun exploration parts of the 3D games. The best visuals on the Wii and the soundtrack is amazing. Taking away .1 for the occasional camera annoyances.

9.5

An excellent and polished game, its loads of fun. The levels are ingeniously designed and very creative. Its probably the best game this gen.