Heavy Rain

Alan Wake

Both look awsome and I plan on getting both. I'd like to see more ingame for Wake though.

To be honest, I'm not quite sure what to think yet about either xD

Heavy rain seems like a game that I've never really played before, and Alan wake looks like it'll play like... I.. dunno o.O;;; I'd need to see gameplay footage from both xD

Both look awesome but I am giving Heavy Rain an edge in terms of awesomeness

Heavy Rain gameplay demo at E3 2008

Is it just me or is the voice acting in Heavy Rain really terrible? Those scenes with the crying woman, they needed someone else to do that voice.

Of`course HEAVY RAIN is better. Heavy Rain - IS a totally NEW gaming experience. =)

The developers of Heavy Rain have proven that they can tell quality stories with Indigo Prophecy. The developers of Alan Wake have proven that they can rip bullet time out of the Matrix and use it in a game and that a game that they should have been able to make in under two years can sometimes take them four years to make.

Do you have any idea how weird this would sound if you were to say it?

As far as I go, I'm all about Heavy Rain right now. I still don't know shit about Alan Wake, and that's a bit ridiculous after 4 years. I'll begin caring when they get the fucking ball rolling with that game. Heavy Rain all day baby!

I dont think either of them look that good.

Both games could be over hyped mediocre style over substance type of games. As in far too ambitious for it's own good.