Even if it gets a 4 its going to sell, anything with Wii on it sells millions sadly.

 I'm looking forward to "Wii Bash n' Troll".

Oh wait... 

Love the crazy reviews deriding Wii Fit, so much fun to read. I can't wait for the American Wii Fit release - it's virtually guaranteed that at least one major review site (1up, I'm looking at you) will deliver an anger-filled Bingo Board rant and hand out a score in the 6-7 range. The resulting flame wars will be... entertaining. :P

Yeah...

1. the stuff it does actually does seem pretty beneficial as Yoga is a very healthy activity. Doing a half hour of yoga a day is equal to many workouts.

2. KFC was advertised as a health food LAST YEAR. You don't know anything about advertising and advertising laws.

3. Halo isn't about angels. You don't fight people in fight night... you play a videogame and you don't really play a guitar in guitar hero.

well....wasn't expecting a high scores anyways. It's good enough to sell millions tho!

1. Yoga can't equal workouts that require you to use alot of energy such as running long distance or rowing a conoe for a mile. , I'd like to see some information that sais otherwise.

2. Dude what country are you in ? KFC would be facing a crazy class action lawsuit in the EU if they advertised it as health food , do you even know why it's called "KFC" and not Kentucky Fried Chicken ?

I probably know far more about advertising law than you do , I study LAW.

3. Your talking about a sci-fi GAME, a boxing video game and comparing it to a Fitness game with a workout board. Your making it sound like the consumer are complete idiots, they aren't , but they are however more gullable than the informed gamer.

If some one sees a game and a gaming board with various workouts you can do on that board then instantly the idea of getting fit while having fun is going to pop into their heads , I'd bet my life that's how Nintendo is marketing it , it's the whole reason they released it , this kinda thing has apeal. It theoreticaly makes a tedius,boring and painful procedure fun and exciting when we know it doesn't work that way.

I said "Wii-Fit can't offer any siginifant health/fitness benefits in comparison to healthy eating , proper exercise (jogging , push up's sit up's Etc Etc)."

" I'm pretty sure it's benefits are negible."

"should not be used purely as a means of loosing Weight or getting fit , regular exercise and a healthy diet should not be neglected.

No where in my post did I say Wii-Fit offers no health benefits , I said the effects are neglible . In order to loose weight you must burn fat , in order to burn fat you must achieve and maintain a level of activity for a prolonged period of time (15minutes)

 Using Wii-Fit for 1 hour might loose you a tiny bit of weight , but it's effects are dwarfed by say, jogging for 25 minutes.

Judging from the following line (the first line in the review), I'd say they made up their mind before even trying it...

"We're sweating bullets - and we haven't even stepped onto the board yet. Of all Nintendo's wacky lifestyle experiments there are none that skirt as close to the game/non-game border as this."

If you can't review the game for what it's meant to be, not by what genre you happen to like, you are an unprofessional, biased reviewer. This reviewer lost all credibility from the first sentance.

http://www.vgchartz.com/forum/thread.php?id=24933&start=0

Wiifit:The professional Opinion. Fitness trainer talks openly about wiifit

that's a topic I made a few days ago, where esquire magazines fitness instructor and expert took to the final version of wiifit to give his impressions. He liked it, and said it would definately be beneficial to people's health, even though it won't replace the benefits of having a personal trainer.

a small snippet from the article

  As for aerobics, reports were similarly positive, James trouncing Wii Fit's pelvis-swivelling Hula Hoop and DDR-like Step games, even if a three-minute whirl around a tropical island as part of the jogging exercise left him slightly out of breath. "The aerobics stuff is fantastic," he states. "It's probably the most beneficial of all the exercises on Wii Fit."