By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - GTA6 reviews thread. Opencritic- 98 / Metacritic - 99

 

GTA6's release has me...

Hyped 9 14.75%
 
Excited 6 9.84%
 
Feeling meh 11 18.03%
 
Hesitant 4 6.56%
 
No feels at all 26 42.62%
 
Repulsed 5 8.20%
 
Total:61
SvennoJ said:
Norion said:

I don't think it should get a 10 due to it having frame drops into the mid 20's but this is still insane. I remember people saying that a 99 wasn't possible any more due to just how many more reviewers there are now compared to 1997 but here we are. This seems to be one hell of an artistic achievement.

Actually more normal (frame drops) then at the time OoT came out when games mostly stuck to the TV refresh rate with zero hitches ;)

It's better than giving a game a higher score for its technical performance as that can always be improved. The content is much harder to improve. As long as it runs well enough (not like CP2077 at release) sticking to 30 fps with a few frame drops shouldn't be held against a game. If it was a VR game it would be more relevant yet even there I loved Firmament with all its early performance issues and never had issues with The Midnight Walk's performance, rightfully won VR game of the year.

Reviews should really be split out in content vs technical performance like blu-ray reviews vs IMDB scores. But I'm sure comparisons between XBone (cloud streaming), Series S/X, PS5/pro will come out soon enough.

I personally wouldn't consider drops into the mid 20's as running well enough but yeah it's nowhere near as bad as Cyberpunk so I wouldn't detract a lot from the score for it. Frame rate is just so important to how good a game feels that some people are gonna have a bit of a rough experience with this version of GTA 6 due to its performance after getting used to 60fps. The idea of splitting content vs technical performance could be nice though.



Around the Network

digital foundry also has an Xbox series video up, the cut backs for series S are rather low but fram rate is bad.

Also I can't pay for fuel..






Please, it is not 1998.



I eat my pants. Shit went well.



konnichiwa said:

digital foundry also has an Xbox series video up, the cut backs for series S are rather low but fram rate is bad.

Also I can't pay for fuel..

The S is a piece of shit.



Around the Network
Random_Matt said:

Please, it is not 1998.

What exactly do you mean?



LegitHyperbole said:
Random_Matt said:

Please, it is not 1998.

What exactly do you mean?

Low frame rates in 98 sure fine but it is 2026 (my impression)






konnichiwa said:
LegitHyperbole said:

What exactly do you mean?

Low frame rates in 98 sure fine but it is 2026 (my impression)

Why? Games are much more complex nowadays while in 1998 they pretty much ran entirely in memory once loaded.




GTA VI is currently at 98.701, so it still has a little breathing room before dropping (or not) to 98.
OOT has a 98.955 rating, but only 22 reviews. When GameRankings was live, OOT was the second-best-rated game of all time, with a 97.54, behind only Super Mario Galaxy at 97.64.



Norion said:
SvennoJ said:

Actually more normal (frame drops) then at the time OoT came out when games mostly stuck to the TV refresh rate with zero hitches ;)

It's better than giving a game a higher score for its technical performance as that can always be improved. The content is much harder to improve. As long as it runs well enough (not like CP2077 at release) sticking to 30 fps with a few frame drops shouldn't be held against a game. If it was a VR game it would be more relevant yet even there I loved Firmament with all its early performance issues and never had issues with The Midnight Walk's performance, rightfully won VR game of the year.

Reviews should really be split out in content vs technical performance like blu-ray reviews vs IMDB scores. But I'm sure comparisons between XBone (cloud streaming), Series S/X, PS5/pro will come out soon enough.

I personally wouldn't consider drops into the mid 20's as running well enough but yeah it's nowhere near as bad as Cyberpunk so I wouldn't detract a lot from the score for it. Frame rate is just so important to how good a game feels that some people are gonna have a bit of a rough experience with this version of GTA 6 due to its performance after getting used to 60fps. The idea of splitting content vs technical performance could be nice though.

Frame rate has always been a bonus to me rather than how good a game feels. Sonic was cool in how smooth and fast it ran, but Doom in a bordered window running sub 20 fps was just as awesome. 

But yeah bring back the score break down. Audio is pretty much always ignored as well while it's half of the experience! How's the music, how are the sound effects, surround sound, lip sync.