By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Suppose Your Favorite Gaming Franchise Hits It Big…

Jumpin said:
HoloDust said:

Fuck no.

It's equivalent of that modern curse "I hope your favorite book gets adapted by Netflix".

Why not? I'd love to see a Netflix or Amazon adaptation of The Silmarillion or Brave New World.

Yes, I know it means the fandoms will be polluted with the shrieking "Netflix/Amazon r**ed my favourite book" attention seeking martyrs; but meh, I don't really do online fan communities besides this one anyway so it doesn't really bother me.

Cause they are utter dogshit (Witcher being prime example). This applies to Amazon (Wheel of Time and Rings of Power are pure unadulterated crap) and Apple as well (Foundation is terrible, bar for one thing).



Around the Network

My current favorite franchise Forza Horizon has been big since the 3rd game and is the reason Forza Motorsports is pretty much dead now. Forza Motorsports pretty much killed Project Gotham Racing so I guess it's fair that it got killed by another racing game.



HoloDust said:
Jumpin said:

Why not? I'd love to see a Netflix or Amazon adaptation of The Silmarillion or Brave New World.

Yes, I know it means the fandoms will be polluted with the shrieking "Netflix/Amazon r**ed my favourite book" attention seeking martyrs; but meh, I don't really do online fan communities besides this one anyway so it doesn't really bother me.

Cause they are utter dogshit (Witcher being prime example). This applies to Amazon (Wheel of Time and Rings of Power are pure unadulterated crap) and Apple as well (Foundation is terrible, bar for one thing).

Well pretty much any movie or show adaptation of a novel is worse than the original source since they always have to add or delete stuff to make it more entertaining or make it fit a particular run time.



Chris Hu said:
HoloDust said:

Cause they are utter dogshit (Witcher being prime example). This applies to Amazon (Wheel of Time and Rings of Power are pure unadulterated crap) and Apple as well (Foundation is terrible, bar for one thing).

Well pretty much any movie or show adaptation of a novel is worse than the original source since they always have to add or delete stuff to make it more entertaining or make it fit a particular run time.

There's "constrained by media" adaptations, and then there's these "adapted by Netllix" and similar garbage.

This is not problem of just adaptations. StarGate revival recently died because "it was too much for original fans" - which is hilarious, cause original StarGate already died once due to studios chasing wider audience with SG:U, thinking they can cater to Battlestar Galactica Reboot's mainstream fans. Amazon's Conan The Barbarian show was scrapped  back in early 2018 cause it was "too masculine", although it was to be faithful adaptation of Howard's work (and apparently, it very much was).

There are IP's that are niche and they're supposed to be niche - not everything is meant to be appreciated by mythical "wider audience", which these streaming wankrods are chasing after. This applies to gaming as well, especially since delivery to end user is easier than ever for niche IPs and genres.



HoloDust said:
Chris Hu said:

Well pretty much any movie or show adaptation of a novel is worse than the original source since they always have to add or delete stuff to make it more entertaining or make it fit a particular run time.

There's "constrained by media" adaptations, and then there's these "adapted by Netllix" and similar garbage.

This is not problem of just adaptations. StarGate revival recently died because "it was too much for original fans" - which is hilarious, cause original StarGate already died once due to studios chasing wider audience with SG:U, thinking they can cater to Battlestar Galactica Reboot's mainstream fans. Amazon's Conan The Barbarian show was scrapped  back in early 2018 cause it was "too masculine", although it was to be faithful adaptation of Howard's work (and apparently, it very much was).

There are IP's that are niche and they're supposed to be niche - not everything is meant to be appreciated by mythical "wider audience", which these streaming wankrods are chasing after. This applies to gaming as well, especially since delivery to end user is easier than ever for niche IPs and genres.

This.

Trying to chase a "wider audience" usually turns games/shows/etc to shit. A game for everyone is a game for no-one.



Around the Network

I'd kind of like to say Fire Emblem, but it did become a fairly evergreen member of Nintendo's pantheon after Awakening even if it didn't sell 30 million copies. Of course, it would have been kind of cool if Fortune's Weave had sold 30 million copies.



Mostly my favorite franchises are dead, so getting a big game once a decade would be fine with me.



The ones I like got worse when they hit big. But at least it might give increased interest in the previous installments as well, spawning mods or copy-cats creating something similar.



You could say that compared to what it used to be, Armored Core VI certainly qualifies as "big", and the game is a fantastic entry into the franchise - almost on par with ACFA. I'd happily wait 10 years again.